Trump Administration Pushes to Centralize Federal Control Over Elections Ahead of the Midterms
The Constitution gives the states and Congress primary authority over how elections are run. Since early 2025, the Trump administration has sought a larger federal role ahead of the November 2026 midterms, cutting federal election-security and oversight offices, sending federal agents to local election offices, demanding states' voter files, and trying to set new voting rules through executive orders and legislation. Trump has said Republicans should "nationalize" the vote.
Investigations by ProPublica and Reuters found that at least 75 career federal officials who worked on elections have since left, been fired, or been reassigned. The cuts reached the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), which helps states protect their voting systems, as well as two Justice Department units: the voting section of the Civil Rights Division, which lost nearly all of its career attorneys, and the Public Integrity Section, which reviews politically sensitive prosecutions and went from roughly 35 to 40 lawyers down to two. Several of the officials brought in as replacements had worked to overturn the 2020 election. In July, Trump also removed the leadership of the Election Assistance Commission, the bipartisan agency that certifies voting equipment and maintains the national voter-registration form, firing two commissioners and accepting the resignation of a third after the fourth had already left. The move came weeks after the Supreme Court, in Trump v. Slaughter, expanded the president's power to fire members of independent agencies, and it was the first time that ruling was applied to an election agency. The commission now has no members, and no replacements have been nominated.
Federal law enforcement has also taken a direct role. In January, the FBI seized Fulton County, Georgia's 2020 ballots on the basis of claims that Georgia's own investigators had already examined and rejected, and in July FBI Director Kash Patel assigned 260 analysts to the case. As of October, the investigation had produced no charges or public findings, and The Atlantic reported that Patel, fielding election-investigation requests that officials said came from the White House, had told staff to "look harder" when inquiries turned up nothing; the FBI called the reporting false. A Reuters investigation separately documented federal officials in at least eight states requesting confidential voter records, seeking access to voting machines, and reopening fraud cases that had already been closed. Internal DHS reports released in October showed that Homeland Security Investigations had also reviewed well over 100 nonprofit voter-registration groups while searching for noncitizen registrations, finding nothing on dozens of them and flagging a few for further investigation.
The administration justifies these steps with two claims: that the 2020 election was stolen and that large numbers of noncitizens vote. Both claims are false. Every state certified the 2020 results, and in the closest states, recounts and reviews, several of them run by Republicans, confirmed Biden's win. Georgia counted its presidential ballots three times, including a full hand recount, and its Republican governor and secretary of state certified the result. In Wisconsin, a recount of the state's two largest counties, which the Trump campaign paid $3 million to request, added 87 votes to Biden's margin. A review commissioned by Arizona's Republican-led state Senate also found that Biden had won, and an investigation by Michigan's Republican-led state Senate found no evidence of widespread fraud. Trump and his allies lost 63 of the 64 lawsuits they brought to overturn the outcome. William Barr, Trump's attorney general at the time, said the Justice Department had found no fraud that could have changed the result. Many of the specific claims Trump promoted were later shown in court to be false. Days after the election, he shared a report that Dominion voting machines had "deleted" 2.7 million of his votes, and he attacked Fox News for calling the race for Biden, urging supporters toward rival networks that had not. Fox hosts and guests then aired claims that Dominion's machines were rigged. In the defamation suit Dominion brought against Fox, a Delaware judge ruled that none of those statements were true, and internal messages released in the case showed Fox hosts privately dismissing the claims while executives worried that viewers would leave for rival networks if Fox stopped airing them. Fox paid Dominion $787.5 million to settle the case in April 2023, as the trial was about to begin. Trump has nonetheless continued to make the claim, at least 107 times over six months by one Reuters count. A New York Times analysis published in October found that he had questioned the integrity of U.S. elections on more than 70 percent of the days since he returned to office. In a July 16 primetime address, he said newly declassified intelligence showed China had interfered in 2020, but the documents he released stated that no foreign country had altered any part of the vote; they instead show that the main foreign influence effort came from Russia, which favored Trump. The White House task force that assembled those documents, led by conservative writer John Solomon, has since produced no evidence of election fraud and has instead released records from past investigations of Trump, the Washington Post reported in October.
The noncitizen figures have been far smaller whenever states have checked them against their own records. In July, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) told Nevada that as many as 15,903 noncitizens might be registered there. When the state asked for the names, DHS provided just 185 voter ID numbers, and in September Nevada reported that its records showed all 185 were citizens. In October, DHS said it had confirmed about 2,000 more Nevada registrants as noncitizens, but Nevada says DHS still has not provided the names or other identifying details needed to check them. DHS put California's figure at as many as 190,832. In October, the Justice Department sent California a list of about 20,000 names and sued to have those voters' ballots set aside, while acknowledging in its complaint that it could not verify the names before the election. Days later, federal prosecutors instead narrowly charged just 28 green-card holders in the state with illegally registering or voting, 22 of whom are accused of casting ballots. California has about 23 million registered voters. These results are consistent with earlier audits, including the conservative Heritage Foundation's database, which records just dozens of noncitizen votes over several decades out of more than a billion ballots cast. The administration's main tool for identifying noncitizens, an expanded DHS database known as SAVE, has also flagged naturalized citizens in error. A federal judge barred its use in June, finding that it had "knowingly trampled on the privacy rights of American citizens," but in September the Supreme Court allowed the government to resume using it while the case is appealed.
Mail voting has been a particular focus. Trump has repeatedly called it dishonest, a claim fact-checkers have found false; studies show that mail-ballot fraud is rare, though somewhat more common than in-person fraud. Because Democrats have voted by mail at higher rates than Republicans since 2020, and because mail ballots are often counted last, results frequently shift toward Democrats as counting continues, a pattern Trump has described as fraud. His March 2025 executive order sought to stop states from counting mail ballots that arrive after Election Day, but in June the Supreme Court ruled 5–4 in Watson v. Republican National Committee that states may count ballots postmarked by Election Day and received later, leaving those grace periods in place in about 30 states. His March 2026 order directed the Postal Service to deliver mail ballots only to voters on federally approved lists. The Postal Service followed with a rule requiring states to submit their mail-voter lists, and the Postmaster General testified that ballots would not be delivered in states that refused. Courts blocked the rule, and in September the Supreme Court declined to let it take effect for the midterms. ProPublica later reported that the White House had first floated requiring every mail ballot to be sent by certified mail, an idea it dropped after Postal Service officials objected that it could not be carried out. In October, as early voting began, Trump urged his supporters to vote early and by mail while continuing to say there is "a lot of cheating" in mail voting.
Courts have ruled against most of the administration's other election efforts as well. The key provisions of both executive orders, including a requirement of documentary proof of citizenship to register, remain blocked. The Justice Department sued 30 states and Washington, D.C., for their full voter files and has lost all 26 cases decided so far, eight of them before judges Trump appointed. In Congress, the SAVE America Act, which would have imposed a proof-of-citizenship requirement nationwide, did not pass the Senate, and Congress has paused until at least December 11 an OMB proposal that would bar the use of federal grant money for voter-registration drives. The Supreme Court has sided with the administration twice, lifting one injunction against the mail-voting order in August and allowing SAVE to be used again in September.
Federal involvement is expanding as voting begins. The Justice Department plans to send a record 1,000 monitors to polling places, while the State Department did not invite observers from the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), which has observed every U.S. federal election since 2002. DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin has said immigration agents could enter polling places to make arrests, and Patel has declined to rule out sending FBI agents. Civil-rights groups and Arlington County, Virginia, have sued to keep armed federal agents away from the polls. The military has said it will not take part. In April, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth testified under oath that President Biden had sent troops to polling places in 15 states in 2024. That testimony was false: Biden sent no troops to polling places, and every state that responded to a CNN inquiry said none of its National Guard members had been stationed at the polls. In August, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff wrote that the military has no plans to deploy troops to polling places in November. Some Republican state officials have also declined federal requests, among them Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger and Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson, who was told she is under federal investigation after she refused to provide Utah's voter data. In a September UC San Diego survey, 49 percent of Americans said they expect the midterms to be free and fair.
Details
Since early 2025, the Trump administration has pursued an effort on several fronts to assert federal control over how Americans vote, an authority the Constitution assigns mainly to the states and Congress. The administration cut the federal offices that worked on election security and removed the members of the bipartisan commission that certifies voting equipment. It demanded voter data from most states, seized 2020 ballots in Georgia before later assigning 260 FBI analysts to the case, and sought records and equipment from local election offices in at least eight states. It also backed legislation and executive orders to require documentary proof of citizenship, and Trump called for Republicans to "nationalize" the vote. In October, as early voting got under way, the administration sued to have as many as 20,000 California ballots set aside. Officials justify these steps as a response to noncitizen voting and a stolen 2020 election, but the available evidence, including audits conducted by Republican officials in Republican-led states, contradicts both claims.
The effort is unfolding ahead of midterms that carry personal stakes for the president. In January, Trump told House Republicans at a party retreat that if they lose the midterms, Democrats "will find a reason to impeach me." With his approval rating near record lows and polling pointing toward possible Republican losses, Democrats who tracked his 2020 efforts have begun asking whether he will accept a result that flips control of a House that impeached him twice.
Part I — The Claim and Its Origins
The 2020 Election and the Claims That Followed
The current dispute over the 2020 election traces back to a December 2020 meeting at Justice Department headquarters, first reported by ProPublica. In a windowless, fortified room, then–Attorney General William Barr summoned roughly ten experts from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), along with FBI officials, to answer whether the presidential vote could have been hacked. The specialists explained that the anomaly in Antrim County, Michigan, which Trump had repeatedly cited, was a clerk's error rather than fraud, a conclusion a hand count soon confirmed. Barr relayed that finding to Trump and then resigned. He was one of many officials, most of them Trump appointees, who declined to act on the fraud claims.
The Legal Record: 64 Cases
Defenders of the fraud claims often argue that the courts never actually examined them, an argument that is not accurate, according to PolitiFact. The 2020 cycle produced more than 400 election-related lawsuits nationwide, making it the most litigated presidential election in recent history. Both parties brought suits, as did campaigns, activists and voters, over issues ranging from mail-ballot deadlines, drop boxes and poll observers to signature-cure rules and pandemic voting accommodations.
Only a fraction of those cases sought to overturn the result, and estimates of that fraction range from roughly three dozen to about 70, depending on how they are counted. One tally, in a 2022 report titled "Lost, Not Stolen" by eight prominent conservatives including former federal judge J. Michael Luttig and former solicitor general Theodore Olson, counted 64 such cases across the six battleground states. Trump and his allies, arguing before judges appointed by both parties and up to the Supreme Court, won one of those cases and lost 63. Twenty were dismissed on standing or procedural grounds before any hearing, 14 were voluntarily withdrawn, and 30 reached a hearing on the merits, where judges ruled against Trump in all but one. The case Trump won, in Pennsylvania, concerned a deadline for voters to "cure" missing identification on mail ballots rather than fraud, and it involved too few votes to affect the result.
Pennsylvania was the center of much of the litigation, and Josh Shapiro, the state's attorney general at the time, said he went "43-0" defending the state's election in court. Where judges did reach the evidence, they rejected it directly. A Nevada court, for example, found that the plaintiffs "did not prove under any standard of proof that illegal votes were cast and counted."
Certification, Recounts, and Audits
Outside the courts, the 2020 result was among the most heavily verified in American history. Every state canvassed and certified its count, and the Electoral College met on December 14. Congress certified the outcome in the early hours of January 7, 2021, after the January 6 attack on the Capitol delayed but did not prevent the proceedings. Because 98 percent of 2020 ballots were cast on paper, officials in the closest states could check machine totals against physical records.
Georgia counted its presidential ballots three times: an initial tally, a full hand recount of nearly 5 million ballots, and a machine recount requested by the Trump campaign. Each count confirmed Biden's win, which Republican Gov. Brian Kemp certified and Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger affirmed, and the state certified the result more than once, the last time on December 7, 2020. In Arizona, Republican Gov. Doug Ducey said Biden had won. A review of Maricopa County ballots commissioned by the Republican-led state Senate reaffirmed Biden's victory and widened his margin, and a separate inquiry by the state's Republican attorney general reached the same conclusion. In Wisconsin, the Trump campaign paid $3 million for a recount of Milwaukee and Dane counties, the state's two largest; the recount added 87 votes to Biden's statewide margin of about 20,600. In Michigan, the state Senate Oversight Committee, led by Republican Sen. Ed McBroom, examined claims ranging from dead voters to signature verification and concluded in June 2021 that it had found no evidence of widespread or systemic fraud.
Trump's own administration reached similar findings. Barr said the Justice Department had found no evidence of fraud that would change the outcome, and CISA called the vote the most secure in U.S. history.
"The Boss Is Not Going to Leave"
Lawyers who had worked on Trump's effort to overturn the result later described to prosecutors what they understood his intentions to be. In a proffer video that ABC News obtained and published in November 2023, former Trump attorney Jenna Ellis, who had pleaded guilty days earlier in the Fulton County, Georgia, racketeering case, told prosecutors in that case about a December 2020 White House gathering. There, she said, White House deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino told her that "the boss is not going to leave under any circumstances. We are just going to stay in power." Ellis said Scavino made the remark just after she noted that the Supreme Court had rejected the campaign's election challenges, and that she came away with the impression he "was serious." In her own proffer, Trump attorney Sidney Powell described a December 18, 2020, Oval Office meeting at which participants discussed plans to seize voting machines. These accounts are one reason Democrats who tracked the 2020 effort are now closely watching the administration's actions ahead of the midterms.
The Shifting Theories and Their Outcomes
The specific explanations offered for a "stolen" 2020 election have changed repeatedly, while the underlying assertion has stayed the same. The first wave of claims, in November and December 2020, centered on mail-in fraud, rigged Dominion voting machines, and "illegal" last-minute changes to state voting rules. After those claims were rejected, attention turned to two Atlanta election workers, Ruby Freeman and her daughter Wandrea' "Shaye" Moss, who were falsely accused of stuffing ballots. It also turned to a set of foreign-interference theories, among them "Italygate," the claim that an Italian defense contractor used satellites to switch votes, which Trump's own team pressed the Justice Department to investigate.
In 2022, Dinesh D'Souza released 2000 Mules, a film alleging that paid "mules" had stuffed drop boxes. That December, the Twitter Files, a series of reports based on internal Twitter documents, recast the story as one of government-directed social-media censorship. From 2024 onward, the emphasis returned to foreign interference, which is the premise of the draft emergency order described below. Each new theory replaced the previous one when evidence to support it did not emerge.
Dominion, Smartmatic, and the Fox Settlement
Trump promoted the voting-machine claims himself. On November 12, 2020, he shared a One America News report claiming that Dominion machines had "deleted" 2.7 million Trump votes nationwide. An Associated Press fact-check traced the claim to anonymous comments on a pro-Trump blog, and CISA said there was "no evidence that any voting system deleted or lost votes, changed votes, or was in any way compromised." The same morning, Trump attacked Fox News for calling the race for Biden, writing that the network had "forgot the Golden Goose," and retweeted posts promoting Newsmax and One America News, which had not called the race. In the weeks that followed, Fox hosts and guests aired claims that Dominion's machines had been rigged to switch votes.
When these claims were tested in adversarial proceedings, they resulted in retractions, settlements, and court losses. Dominion sued Fox for defamation, and internal messages released during discovery showed that Fox hosts privately doubted the claims the network was airing. Tucker Carlson texted Laura Ingraham that "Sidney Powell is lying," and wrote of the network's audience, "Our viewers are good people and they believe it." Sean Hannity testified that he "did not believe it for one second." Executives worried that viewers would switch to Newsmax and One America News if Fox stopped airing the claims, and after Fox White House correspondent Jacqui Heinrich fact-checked one of Trump's posts about Dominion, Carlson urged that she be fired, writing, "It's measurably hurting the company. The stock price is down." Rupert Murdoch, Fox's controlling owner, acknowledged in a deposition that some of the network's hosts had endorsed the false fraud claims.
On March 31, 2023, Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric Davis ruled that it was "CRYSTAL clear that none of the Statements relating to Dominion about the 2020 election are true," leaving a jury to decide only whether Fox had acted with actual malice. On April 18, as the trial was about to begin, Fox agreed to pay Dominion $787.5 million, one of the largest known media defamation settlements in U.S. history, in a statement acknowledging "the Court's rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false." Smartmatic, the other voting-technology company named in the fraud claims, settled its defamation suits with One America News in April 2024 and with Newsmax that September, reportedly for $40 million in the Newsmax case.
Giuliani, Powell, and the Defamation Cases
Rudy Giuliani, the former New York City mayor who promoted the story that Freeman and Moss had stuffed ballots, conceded in July 2023 that his statements about the two women were false. That December, a federal jury ordered him to pay them $148 million. Sidney Powell, who filed the "Kraken" lawsuits alleging a vast Dominion conspiracy, responded to Dominion's defamation claim against her by arguing in a 2021 filing that "no reasonable person would conclude that the statements were truly statements of fact."
2000 Mules, Gateway Pundit, and the Retractions
The Gateway Pundit, a conservative website whose founder, Jim Hoft, published many of the false stories about the Atlanta election workers, settled with Freeman and Moss in October 2024. The site, which had maintained for years that the women committed fraud, then posted a note from its editor about the resolution. Earlier that year, in May 2024, Salem Media, the film's distributor, pulled 2000 Mules from all platforms and apologized after a Georgia man whom the film had implicated filed suit. D'Souza apologized to that man in December 2024.
The Censorship Theory: Hines v. Stamos
The theory that the 2020 result was engineered through a government-coordinated censorship operation, advanced in the Twitter Files and by figures such as Matt Taibbi, Michael Shellenberger, and Mike Benz, produced its own lawsuit, which was also dismissed. On May 2, 2023, America First Legal, the legal group founded by White House aide Stephen Miller, sued on behalf of Jill Hines and the Gateway Pundit's Jim Hoft. The suit alleged that the Election Integrity Partnership (EIP) and the Virality Project, research collaborations involving the Stanford Internet Observatory, the University of Washington, Graphika, and the Atlantic Council, had run "an unconstitutional censorship scheme" that surveilled and suppressed conservative speech.
On July 1, 2026, after court-ordered discovery on jurisdictional questions, U.S. District Judge Terry A. Doughty of the Western District of Louisiana dismissed the case in full and without prejudice (Hines v. Stamos, No. 3:23-cv-00571-TAD-KDM). He held that the plaintiffs lacked standing and that the court lacked jurisdiction over the defendants. The ruling drew attention because Doughty had earlier been sympathetic to the censorship theory as the trial judge in Murthy v. Missouri, a challenge to federal officials' communications with social-media companies. In the new opinion, he found that "discovery has confirmed the absence of any factual basis to conclude the EIP or VP, let alone any particular Defendant, coerced any social media platform to censor Plaintiffs' posts or accounts." When Facebook and Twitter restricted the plaintiffs' content, the court found, the companies acted under their own policies rather than at the researchers' direction, and it noted that Facebook had labeled one Gateway Pundit post hours before EIP flagged it. The opinion applied the standard the Supreme Court set in Murthy, under which "coercion is beyond mere communication."
Some Republicans have also questioned the party's continued emphasis on fraud. Asked in late June 2026 how the party's continued focus on fraud fit with its support for the SAVE America Act, the proof-of-citizenship bill, Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky said: "It's ironic that we control the House, Senate, Supreme Court, and the White House—and we're yelling 'election fraud'? … We won all the damn elections."
Continued False Claims, 2021–2026
Trump's false statements about elections have continued throughout the period in which the administration has taken these institutional steps. A Reuters tally found that over roughly six months, Trump claimed at least 107 times that the 2020 election was rigged, an average of more than once every two days. Election experts told Reuters that the repetition is not incidental but a deliberate effort to build a justification for contesting or intervening in races Republicans could lose in 2026.
A broader count reached a similar result. On October 9, 2026, the New York Times published, and later updated, an analysis by Karen Yourish and Arfa Momin of Trump's public remarks and Truth Social posts from January 20, 2025, through October 13, 2026, drawn from Roll Call's Factbase. It found that Trump had cast doubt on U.S. elections on 449 days, more than 70 percent of the days in his second term. He called the 2020 election "rigged" on his first day back in office, in remarks before his inaugural luncheon. He now says he won three presidential elections, in 2016, 2020 and 2024, though he won two. He also says that Democrats use immigrants without legal status to "cheat," although noncitizen voting is rare, and that mail ballots produce fraudulent results, for which there is no evidence. He has said that Democrats will "cheat" in the midterms unless Congress passes the SAVE America Act. White House spokesperson Lauren Bis told the Times that "the evidence of voter fraud continues to pile up" and that Democrats' refusal to vote for the bill is "keeping Americans from having full confidence in their elections."
The claims have extended into the current cycle. Within two weeks ahead of California's June primaries, Trump asserted that he would have won the state with an honest count, that California does not allow people to vote in person, and that the state mails out 15 million excess ballots. Each claim was false, according to a CNN fact-check: California offers in-person voting at polling places and vote centers, and it mails ballots to registered active voters rather than to millions of surplus recipients. Critics describe a recurring sequence in which fraud is asserted without evidence and the resulting distrust is then cited as grounds for federal action.
In late June, Trump said he had directed a federal prosecutor to intervene in California's primary. Speaking at a Pennsylvania truck facility on June 23 and again in the Oval Office on June 24, he said that after the June 2 primary he had called "the very powerful, very good U.S. attorney in California" and told the prosecutor, "Do me a favor. Take a look. They are trying to steal that election." He claimed that, as a result, the Republican candidate for governor, former Fox News host Steve Hilton, advanced to the November runoff. The account echoed the "do us a favor" phrasing from Trump's 2019 call with Ukraine's president, which was at the center of his first impeachment.
No evidence of fraud in the primary has emerged, and it was unclear what a prosecutor could have done to change a vote count; California's slow tallies reflect state laws designed to maximize participation. California also has no single U.S. attorney, since the state is divided into four federal judicial districts. On June 5, Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, had announced "multiple election fraud investigations." Hilton said he had no knowledge of any such call, and Los Angeles County's elections chief said no one at the Justice Department had influenced the county's operations. Gov. Gavin Newsom's office called the remarks an admission that "the President of the United States is personally directing federal prosecutors to start investigations into his political opponents when his preferred candidate may lose the election."
Trump has also made false claims about his own popularity, which some analysts argue serve a similar purpose. In a July 10, 2026, opinion column for New York magazine's Intelligencer, Ed Kilgore argued that Trump's "poll denialism" conditions supporters to treat any electoral loss as fraud, on the reasoning that a president this popular could lose only through cheating. Kilgore documents what he describes as fabricated or cherry-picked numbers. On June 29, 2026, with his approval near all-time lows, Trump posted, "Highest Poll Numbers Ever. Even Higher than Election Day," when the Silver Bulletin polling average showed 39.5 percent approval and 57.4 percent disapproval. In November 2025, he claimed the "HIGHEST POLL NUMBERS OF MY 'POLITICAL CAREER'" without citing any source, while polling averages put his approval at 41 percent. At the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in February 2025, he cited outlier polls showing approval from the mid-50s to the low 70s, when the average stood at 48.7 percent.
Kilgore notes that this denialism predates 2020 and has appeared in every race Trump has contested. Trump claimed that massive illegal voting cost him the popular vote in 2016, described his roughly 1.5-point popular-vote margin in 2024 as a historic landslide, and now attributes Republican losses in states such as California to fraud. In Kilgore's judgment, this record indicates that Trump will not accept a Democratic victory in the 2026 midterms.
Part II — What the Evidence Shows
How Officials Detect Voter Fraud
The administration's case largely leaves out how American elections detect illegal voting, which is how officials know the rate is low. Election officials rely on a set of overlapping checks that can each be verified independently, and most of them leave a paper record.
Registration Screening: HAVA and ERIC
Screening begins when a voter registers. The Help America Vote Act requires every state to keep a centralized registration list and to verify each new applicant against motor-vehicle and Social Security records, a check the Social Security Administration performs for 45 states. States also maintain their rolls by cross-checking them against other states' rolls and against federal death records through the Electronic Registration Information Center (ERIC), a multistate data-sharing program.
Casting a Ballot: ID Requirements, Poll Books, and Signature Matching
Further checks apply when a ballot is cast. Electronic poll books, which were used across 41 states in 2024, flag anyone who has already voted, and a voter whose eligibility is uncertain casts a provisional ballot that counts only after officials confirm it. For ballots returned by mail, most states verify the signature on each one against the signature in the voter's file.
There is no national voter ID requirement. Thirty-six states ask voters for identification at the polls, with about two dozen accepting photo ID and the rest also accepting non-photo documents. The other fourteen states and Washington, D.C., verify identity by signature or other means.
Whether ID laws matter is among the most heavily studied questions in election research, and the findings do not fully support either side of the debate. The largest analysis, a 2021 study in the Quarterly Journal of Economics drawing on 1.6 billion records across a decade of elections, found that strict ID laws had essentially no effect on turnout, either overall or for any racial group, and no measurable effect on a rate of fraud that was already minute. Some earlier work had reported larger effects. A widely cited 2017 study found that strict laws substantially reduced Latino turnout, but a reanalysis identified coding errors that, once corrected, eliminated the result. A Government Accountability Office study did find modest turnout declines of two to three points in Kansas and Tennessee after those states tightened their laws, with the declines concentrated among young and Black voters, and a 2017 review of the research concluded that the turnout effects are "modest, if any." The research does not show that ID requirements catch meaningful fraud, because the type of fraud they target, one voter impersonating another at the polls, is extremely rare.
After the Count: Audits and Paper Trails
A growing number of states confirm the machine tally after an election by hand-counting random samples of paper ballots: 15 states use risk-limiting audits and 45 require some post-election review. Because about 98 percent of 2024 ballots left a paper trail, those audits and any recounts rest on physical evidence. This system of checks is what led federal cybersecurity officials and their state counterparts to call the 2020 election the most secure in American history.
Testing the Fraud Claims
Noncitizen Voting
The administration describes its actions as enforcement of existing law against noncitizen voting. "Election integrity has always been a top priority for President Trump," White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said, pledging to ensure "only American citizens are voting."
Studies of how often noncitizens actually vote have reached consistent results. A study by the Brennan Center, a law and policy institute at New York University, examined 23.5 million votes cast in 42 jurisdictions in 2016 and found about 30 cases of suspected noncitizen voting, or roughly 0.0001 percent, with 40 of the 42 jurisdictions reporting none. The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, maintains a fraud database that documents only dozens of noncitizen-voting cases over decades in which more than a billion votes were cast, and analyses of that database find that most of the cases involve lawful permanent residents, often ones who had been misinformed by officials. Voting as a noncitizen is already a felony that can lead to prison or deportation, and the federal registration form requires applicants to attest to their citizenship under penalty of perjury.
Recent state reviews, many of them run by Republican officials, have found similarly small numbers. In Utah, Republican Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson reviewed all 2.1 million voters and found a single noncitizen registrant, who had never voted. Henderson, who was herself once wrongly flagged because she was born abroad to a U.S. service member, said there is no widespread problem. Idaho's Republican secretary of state validated 36 noncitizens out of 1.1 million, Georgia's Republican secretary of state, Brad Raffensperger, found 20 out of 8.2 million, and Montana identified 23 out of about 763,000. Louisiana's Republican secretary of state reported 390 noncitizen registrations and 79 votes spread across decades and said it was not a systemic problem. In Michigan, a Republican county clerk's claim of 15 noncitizens was reduced to four on review, and one verified citizen had been wrongly placed under criminal investigation. Nationwide, a New York Times analysis found that of 49.5 million registrations run through SAVE, the federal government's immigration-status verification system, 0.02 percent were flagged as potential noncitizens, a figure that itself includes false positives.
Similar claims have been examined before. In 2017, Trump formed the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity to investigate his claim that millions of people voted illegally in 2016. The commission disbanded within months without producing evidence, and records that one of its members obtained through a court showed that a draft section on fraud was empty. More recently, Stephen Richer, the Republican who oversaw voter registration in Maricopa County, wrote that he had found two possible noncitizen votes among 2.5 million registrations, and he concluded that the issue is mostly about scoring political points and fundraising.
Impersonation and "Dead Voter" Claims
In-person impersonation is the rarest documented form of election fraud. It is a felony that yields a single vote and is easily caught, since the impersonator must gamble that the real voter has not already voted and will not notice. A comprehensive canvass by law professor Justin Levitt found 31 credible incidents between 2000 and 2014 out of more than a billion ballots cast, and an investigation by News21, a student reporting project, reviewed 2,068 alleged fraud cases since 2000 and counted ten. One survey experiment found that the share of people who reported having impersonated a voter was statistically indistinguishable from the share who reported having been abducted by extraterrestrials. As Levitt summarized it, an American is likelier to be struck by lightning than to impersonate a voter at the polls.
The "dead voter" claim confuses a name on a voter list with a ballot cast. Voter rolls always lag behind deaths, because a death must be certified and reported before a registration can be canceled, and federal law bars states from running systematic removal programs in the 90 days before a federal election. As a result, some deceased people remain registered on every Election Day. States find and remove them through death records and the ERIC cross-match, but a registration that remains on the rolls after a death is not a vote.
When the 2020 claims were checked, nearly all proved false. Raffensperger investigated Trump's assertion that Georgia had thousands of dead voters and confirmed four cases, each involving a relative who had returned a recently deceased family member's absentee ballot. The Arizona Senate's audit alleged 282 dead voters, and the state attorney general confirmed one. A Pennsylvania lawsuit that claimed more than 21,000 dead registrants conflated registration with voting and was rejected by a federal judge. A Michigan audit found 2,775 ballots recorded from people listed as deceased, or 0.02 percent of the vote, but 98.5 percent of those voters had voted legally by mail and then died before Election Day. A Stanford study of 4.5 million records in Washington State found at most fourteen ballots that may have been cast in the names of dead people, a rate of 0.0003 percent.
Two of the confirmed cases involved Republicans. In Pennsylvania, Bruce Bartman, a registered Republican, requested an absentee ballot in his dead mother's name and cast it for Trump. He pleaded guilty and told the judge he had "listened to too much propaganda." In Nevada, Donald Kirk Hartle, a Republican, publicly claimed that someone had fraudulently voted his late wife's ballot, a story that conservative media amplified, but it turned out that he had cast the ballot himself.
Double Voting Across State Lines
Research on double voting has reached a similar conclusion. A 2020 study in the American Political Science Review estimated roughly one apparent double vote for every 4,000 voters in 2012. The authors then showed that a clerical-error rate of just 1.3 percent would account for all of them, and that removing registrations aggressively enough to stop those votes would cancel more than 300 legitimate registrations for every double vote prevented.
What the Academic Literature Finds
Researchers have measured fraud through several independent methods, including prosecution records, journalistic case counts, survey experiments, and record-matching audits. Each method has different blind spots, yet all of them find rates far too low to affect an election outcome. Findings that appear to show otherwise have generally been traced to measurement error. When two researchers used a 2014 survey to estimate that more than a million noncitizens had voted in 2008, other scholars showed that a survey misclassification rate of just 0.1 percent, meaning a few citizens mistakenly checking "noncitizen," was enough to produce the entire result. Among respondents who identified as noncitizens consistently across two waves of the survey, none had cast a validated vote.
The evidence does not show that fraud is literally zero, and skeptics make several accurate points. Citizenship is generally not cross-checked at the polls, so a determined noncitizen who registers can go undetected for a time. A low number of prosecutions partly reflects how hard fraud is to detect, not only how rare it is. Isolated cases do occur and are prosecuted. In addition, the bipartisan 2005 Commission on Federal Election Reform, known as the Carter-Baker Commission and co-chaired by former President Jimmy Carter, called absentee ballots "the largest source of potential voter fraud," and skeptics of mail voting often cite that finding. The commission, however, was ranking a risk within a category that all subsequent data show is very small in absolute terms, and it did not recommend reducing mail voting. What the weight of the evidence rules out is not the occasional fraudulent ballot but fraud on a scale that could change who wins, which is the premise behind the administration's current efforts.
Mail-In Ballots: Partisan Use and the Blue Shift
Why Mail Ballots Lean Democratic
Mail ballots lean Democratic because of which voters choose to use them, not because of fraud, a point that criticism of the method rarely acknowledges. Before 2020 there was little partisan difference in voting by mail. That changed in 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic led to a large expansion of mail voting, Trump spent the campaign describing it as fraudulent, and Democrats urged their voters to use it. By that November, nearly 60 percent of Democrats but only about 30 percent of Republicans cast mail ballots, according to MIT's survey of the electorate. The gap has since narrowed as some Republican strategists have promoted early voting, but the partisan split persists: 37 percent of Democrats and 24 percent of Republicans voted by mail in 2024. Because the pool of mail voters is disproportionately Democratic, any batch of mail ballots counted on its own tends to favor Democrats.
The "Red Mirage" and Election-Night Leads
That self-selection, combined with the order in which each kind of ballot is counted, produces the patterns known as the "red mirage" and the "blue shift," which Trump has repeatedly described as evidence of theft. Ohio State election-law scholar Edward Foley documented the pattern as early as 2013 and found versions of it in election after election. In-person votes, which skew Republican, are usually counted first. Mail and provisional ballots take longer to process and are cast disproportionately by younger, lower-income and more mobile voters who lean Democratic, so they are counted later, and early returns can therefore show a Republican lead that shrinks as the count proceeds.
Foley and MIT's Charles Stewart projected that the effect would be larger than usual in 2020, and it was. It was largest in states such as Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, where state law barred officials from processing mail ballots until Election Day, so hundreds of thousands of Democratic-leaning mail votes were tallied only after the in-person totals. Trump led Pennsylvania by roughly 690,000 votes early on November 4, 2020, before the mail count erased that margin, and in Wisconsin a batch of absentee ballots reported before dawn reversed his lead. In states that let officials process mail ballots before Election Day, as Florida does, the count finishes faster and the shift is barely noticeable, which indicates that the swing results from counting rules rather than from any change in the votes. Trump nonetheless cited the shift as it was happening and demanded that officials "STOP THE COUNT."
What Trump Has Said About Mail Voting
Trump has also repeatedly criticized mail voting itself. As the litigation over absentee ballots advanced toward the Supreme Court, he made several claims about mail-in voting that fact-checkers have long debunked, and CNN's Daniel Dale examined a number of them in a March 24, 2026 fact-check. Dale found that Trump's assertion that mail-in voting is "really dishonest" is false, because it is a legitimate method used by legitimate voters, Trump among them, and all available evidence shows that fraud rates are tiny, even if slightly higher than for in-person voting.
Trump also mischaracterized what Carter and the 2005 Commission on Federal Election Reform concluded. Carter never said "you can't have" mail ballots, and the commission did not say cheating was inevitable. Although it was skeptical of mail voting, the commission highlighted Oregon's successful mail-only elections after that state adopted safeguards, recommended ways to make mail voting more secure, and called for further research. Trump's claim that the US is the "only country in the world that does this type of mail-in ballot" is misleading rather than provably false, since he did not define "this type." Dozens of countries use mail-in ballots, and several wealthy democracies, including Canada, the United Kingdom, Germany and Switzerland, permit widespread use.
Trump has made a similar claim on a separate issue. In an April 21, 2026 CNBC interview, he repeated his previously debunked claim that the US is the "only nation" with birthright citizenship. In fact, about three dozen countries grant it, including Canada, Mexico and most of South America.
Trump has kept describing mail voting as fraudulent while urging his supporters to use it. On October 3, 2026, he posted a pre-recorded video to Truth Social telling Republicans, "If your state has early voting, do not wait. Go out and vote. Vote early, vote by mail, or vote in person on Election Day," and pointed viewers to "Swamp the Vote USA," a program his 2024 campaign launched to promote absentee, mail and early voting, CNN reported. CNN asked the White House whether the video marked a shift in his views and reported no response. Trump repeated the message on the campaign trail. On October 9 in New York, he told voters to request mail ballots by October 24 and have them postmarked by Election Day, adding, "I always like Election Day better." At an October 13 rally in Wasilla, Alaska, he said, "vote early, vote by mail, or vote on Election Day," and told mail voters to track their ballots, the Alaska Beacon reported. On October 5, 2026, as he left the White House for a campaign rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, a reporter asked him why he was telling his supporters to vote by mail if he thought it was fraud. Trump said he would "rather have them vote in person, but they can vote by mail if they want, because we seem to have no choice," and added, "there is a lot of cheating in vote by mail." He pointed to California. When the reporter said there was no evidence of that in California, Trump replied, "No evidence with millions and millions of ballots? You are fake news," according to a Roll Call Factbase transcript and video of the exchange. The available evidence does not support the claim. CNN's March 24 fact-check found that fraud rates in federal elections are tiny even with mail ballots, and that California sends mail ballots only to active registered voters and checks the signature on each returned envelope before counting it. The same fact-check noted that Trump encouraged his supporters to vote by mail in 2024 and voted by mail himself in a Florida special election in March 2026.
Part III — The Federal Campaign, 2025–2026
"Team America" and the Officials Now in Charge
ProPublica describes a small group of DHS political appointees, calling itself "Team America," that was convened to find federal levers for implementing Trump's March 2025 election order. Its core members included David Harvilicz, a DHS assistant secretary who oversees election-infrastructure security. The outlet previously reported that Harvilicz co-founded an AI company with an architect of the claims that voting machines in Antrim County, Michigan, were hacked in 2020, and that he has said he wants to ban voting machines. Working under him is Heather Honey, who originated the false claim that more ballots than voters were cast in Pennsylvania in 2020, a claim Trump cited on January 6, 2021.
Honey is one of at least 11 administration appointees with ties to the Election Integrity Network, the group led by Cleta Mitchell, a lawyer who worked to help Trump overturn the 2020 result. Brendan Fischer of the Campaign Legal Center told ProPublica that the election-denial movement "is now interwoven within the federal government," having shifted from the "last-minute slapdash attempts" of 2020 to systematic efforts months ahead of an election. A DHS spokesperson disputed that the department's officials sought to advantage Trump, saying they are "focused on keeping our elections safe, secure, and free" and that DHS hires "experts with diverse backgrounds who go through a rigorous vetting process."
One concrete project Team America advanced was running state voter rolls through SAVE (Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements), a Homeland Security tool, to find noncitizens. More recently, according to two sources, the group has moved toward harnessing a more powerful Homeland Security Investigations tool to search for noncitizen voters and pursue criminal charges. DHS said SAVE flagged more than 21,000 potential noncitizens on voter rolls over the past year and called the system "secure and reliable." In the states that adopted it, however, its accuracy quickly became a problem.
Cuts to Federal Election-Security Offices
An April 2026 ProPublica investigation by Doug Bock Clark and Jen Fifield, based on interviews with roughly 30 current and former officials, found that at least 75 career officials who did elections work at the departments of Homeland Security and Justice and other agencies have left, been fired or been reassigned. The roughly two dozen people installed in their place include ten who worked to reverse the 2020 vote.
Cuts at CISA
Trump created the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) in his first term, after Russia's interference in the 2016 election. The agency had debunked numerous fraud claims and, together with state officials, declared the 2020 vote "the most secure in American history," a statement that cost its director, Chris Krebs, his job. ProPublica reports that cutting the agency's election work was among Trump's first actions of his second term. Starting in February 2025, staff focused on disinformation and election safeguards were placed on leave and the agency's election-security assessments were frozen, and the roughly three dozen CISA employees who specialized in elections were eventually fired or transferred. Kathy Boockvar, a former Pennsylvania secretary of state, told ProPublica that the loss of CISA's election work "leaves a gaping hole" in capabilities built over years of bipartisan work. A DHS spokesperson said the changes addressed "a ballooning budget concealing a dangerous departure from its statutory mission" and that CISA still coordinates critical-infrastructure protection.
A follow-up ProPublica investigation, published October 19, 2026, found that the administration has laid off or pushed out more than 1,000 CISA employees, roughly a third of the agency, and that election officials received little or no help from CISA as they planned for the midterms. The agency did not publish its 2026 election-security plan until September 24, which Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows and others said was too late to matter. The investigation also reported that DHS political appointees had asked CISA to secretly buy a voting machine, examine it and report the findings to the White House, and that staff were reportedly told not to notify the vendor of any flaws they found. Career employees objected that the request was not feasible, in part because the staff who could have done the work had been laid off, and the appointees eventually dropped it.
Other Agencies and the Justice Department
ProPublica's reporting also describes cuts elsewhere in the government. The National Security Council's election-security group was eliminated, and in August the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) closed its Foreign Malign Influence Center, which had countered Russian, Chinese and Iranian interference in 2024. At the FBI, Director Kash Patel disbanded the bureau's public corruption team and its Foreign Influence Task Force. ODNI said the influence center was redundant and that its functions had been folded elsewhere, and the FBI said it "remains committed to detecting and countering foreign influence." Former officials told ProPublica, however, that the functions had largely ceased. Caitlin Durkovich, who ran the NSC's election-security work under Biden, said that heading into the midterms nearly every capability to support election administrators and stop bad actors had been eliminated.
Two Justice Department offices that served as internal checks were also cut. The Public Integrity Section, which vetted politically sensitive cases, was reduced from roughly 35–40 lawyers to about two after a wave of resignations that began when department leadership ordered the dismissal of corruption charges against then–New York City Mayor Eric Adams (covered in a separate entry). The administration no longer requires the unit to review such cases.
The second office, the Civil Rights Division's voting section, enforces anti-discrimination voting law. It lost nearly all of its roughly 30 career attorneys after Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon, who heads the division, issued a memo redirecting its mission from protecting voting rights to enforcing Trump's election executive order. The administration then staffed the section with conservative lawyers, at least four of whom challenged the 2020 vote or worked with those who did. Anna Baldwin, a former appellate attorney in the division who now litigates against the department at the Campaign Legal Center, described the change as a depressing reversal of the government's role in nondiscrimination in voting.
In October 2026, The New York Times reported that Dhillon had named Eric Neff, a former Los Angeles County prosecutor, as acting head of the voting section. In 2022, the county district attorney's office placed Neff on administrative leave after it withdrew his indictment of a software company executive accused of storing poll-worker data on a Chinese server, citing irregularities in the case, and the county later paid the company $5 million to settle, according to the Times. The division also hired David Michael Levin, who pleaded guilty to two misdemeanors in 2016 after twice hacking into the Lee County, Florida, election system. Dhillon said the new hires had "collectively tried hundreds of cases." The division's broader hiring is covered in a separate entry.
The Election Assistance Commission
On July 9, 2026, Trump removed the leadership of the U.S. Election Assistance Commission (EAC), the bipartisan federal panel Congress created after the disputed 2000 election to strengthen and secure voting. The Washington Post reported that Trump fired the commission's two Democratic members, Chair Thomas Hicks and Benjamin Hovland, and accepted the resignation of Republican commissioner Christy McCormick. According to Votebeat, the terminations arrived by email stating "your position as Commissioner of the Election Assistance Commission is terminated, effective immediately." Because the fourth commissioner, Republican Donald Palmer, had left voluntarily in April 2026 for the Heritage Foundation, the removals left the EAC with no commissioners at all. By statute, no more than two of the body's four members may belong to the same party, and any replacements would need confirmation by the Republican-controlled Senate. The White House did not say whether or when Trump would name successors.
The commission's work bears directly on the midterms. It maintains the national mail voter registration form, tests and certifies voting equipment, distributes federal election-security funds, and issues guidance to state and local officials. Trump's March 2025 executive order had directed the EAC to redesign the federal form to require documentary proof of citizenship, one of the provisions courts blocked. According to the Institute for Responsive Government, a nonprofit cited by the Post, EAC staff can continue certifying equipment, disbursing funds and maintaining the form, but they cannot establish new policies or guidelines without commissioners. As a result, decisions on voting-system certifications and the federal form are effectively frozen ahead of November.
The firings came less than two weeks after the Supreme Court's late-June ruling in Trump v. Slaughter, which allowed Trump to fire a Democratic member of the Federal Trade Commission. That decision overturned decades of precedent and gave presidents broad power over agencies designed to be independent, although a decision issued the same day shielded the Federal Reserve Board. The EAC removals are among the first applications of the Slaughter ruling to a bipartisan election body, and they could prompt new litigation testing its reach. "It's an open question about the EAC and the Federal Election Commission" whether bipartisan election agencies retain removal protections, election-law scholar Rick Hasen told Votebeat.
The White House said the president "reserves the right to remove individuals that may not be totally aligned with the important task of securing America's elections and ensuring every legal vote is counted." Sen. Alex Padilla and Rep. Joe Morelle, the top Democrats on the committees overseeing election policy, called the move "a blatant part of his plan to politicize our elections" and said Americans deserve elections "not overseen by partisan loyalists and election deniers beholden to Trump." Democracy Docket reported that election chiefs and lawmakers called the firings "dangerous," "reckless" and "desperate," and ProPublica and NBC News also covered the removals.
In August the commission adopted a succession plan "in lieu of a Commission Quorum," leaving day-to-day operations to its executive director. As of mid-October, Trump had not nominated anyone to fill the four vacant seats, and the EAC will go through the midterms without a single commissioner.
The Executive Orders and the Courts
Courts have blocked much of the administration's program. Trump's March 2025 executive order sought to require documentary proof of citizenship on the federal voter-registration form, to penalize states that count mail ballots arriving after Election Day, and to withhold election funds from states that did not comply. The Constitution's Elections Clause assigns the "times, places and manner" of federal elections to the states and Congress, and a Brookings analysis concluded that it leaves "no space for presidential authority" over election rules. On June 24, 2026, U.S. District Judge Denise Casper in Boston permanently blocked most of the order, writing that the Constitution "does not grant the President any specific powers over elections" and that the Justice Department had failed to substantiate its claims of "widespread illegal voting." Casper's court was the third to strike down the order; federal judges in Washington, D.C., had previously enjoined its citizenship requirement and barred its application to military voters.
Trump's second order, issued in March 2026 after the SAVE America Act stalled in the Senate, would have directed DHS to build federal lists of eligible voters and ordered the Postal Service to deliver mail ballots only to people on those lists. On June 25, the day after Casper's ruling, U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani blocked its key provisions for the 24 jurisdictions that sued, finding that federal agencies "lack the ability to create complete and accurate lists" and that "both Congress and the president lack any role regarding voter eligibility." In rejecting the order's attempt to give the Postal Service authority over who could vote by mail, Talwani also wrote that the Constitution "does not grant the President any specific powers over elections," underlining the words "does not" for emphasis, as The Atlantic noted. The White House said it expects to "ultimately prevail" on appeal.
The Postal Service, meanwhile, had released a proposed rule of its own in June to implement the second order. Under it, postal employees would screen mail ballots against state-provided voter lists and withhold delivery where states refused to comply. At a Senate Homeland Security Committee hearing on June 24, 2026, Postmaster General David Steiner confirmed that consequence. Asked by Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI) whether the Postal Service would still deliver ballots in a state that declined to hand over its absentee-voter list, Steiner answered: "Under our proposed regulation, no." The answer reversed his earlier assurance that the agency would "absolutely" keep delivering mail ballots and defer to the courts. Democrats warned that the rule would force states either to hand over voter data or to lose mail voting for millions of Americans, and Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) urged Steiner not to let the Postal Service become "a pawn in this authoritarian playbook." At the time, the regulation was in a 30-day public-comment period, with a final rule due by the end of July.
Days later, the Supreme Court ruled on the separate question of late-arriving mail ballots. On June 29, 2026, in Watson v. Republican National Committee, a challenge to Mississippi's grace period for absentee ballots, the Court ruled 5–4 that federal law does not bar states from counting absentee ballots postmarked by Election Day but received afterward, and it upheld the Mississippi law. Justice Amy Coney Barrett, a Trump appointee, wrote for a majority that included Chief Justice John Roberts and the three Democratic-appointed justices. Justice Samuel Alito dissented, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch and, in part, by Justice Brett Kavanaugh. The majority rejected the reading of Election Day as a deadline for receiving ballots, the theory behind Trump's first executive order and behind a nationwide Republican litigation campaign, which the administration's solicitor general had urged the Court to adopt. The decision left grace periods in place for November in roughly 30 states, and 14 of those states, along with Washington, D.C., allow them for all mail ballots. Mississippi's Republican attorney general, who had defended the law in court, nonetheless urged state lawmakers to repeal the window. Trump called the decision a tremendous loss and renewed his demand that the Senate pass the SAVE America Act, writing that the only reason to oppose it was "CHEATING."
The Litigation Record as of July
By early July, an Atlantic analysis by Toluse Olorunnipa tallied the administration's record in court. The Justice Department had lost at least a dozen election lawsuits, and over a two-week span district judges had ruled against both of Trump's major voting executive orders, blocked the administration's demands for state voter rolls, and barred the government's modified version of the SAVE citizenship-verification system. Those rulings came months after Trump said on February 13 that he had "searched the depths of Legal Arguments not yet articulated or vetted" and found an "irrefutable" theory that would let him bypass Congress and impose voting rules, including a national voter-ID requirement, for the midterms. David Becker, executive director of the Center for Election Innovation & Research and a former DOJ voting-section attorney, said of the administration: "It is losing literally every single case it's involved in. I can't remember the DOJ or any administration losing more than one or two trial-court cases a year, at the most. We are well into the double digits with this administration, and the year is not even half over yet." A Justice Department spokesperson said the administration is "devoting significant resources" to the litigation, and White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said clean voter rolls were a campaign pledge that is "why millions of Americans sent him back to the White House."
The Atlantic noted that the string of losses echoed the aftermath of 2020, when a Washington Post review found that 86 judges had ruled against Trump or his supporters within a month of Biden's victory. The analysis also catalogued areas where Trump has succeeded in reshaping the electoral landscape. In April, the Supreme Court's ruling in Louisiana v. Callais narrowed the Voting Rights Act and cleared the way for Republican-led states to redraw congressional maps eliminating Democratic-leaning districts with large minority populations. In early July, the Court rolled back campaign-finance restrictions on political parties, a decision Trump hailed as "A BIG WIN FOR REPUBLICANS." In the states, a Center for American Progress report by Gréta Bedekovics and Devon Ombres found that at least 12 have passed laws since 2024 requiring documentary proof of citizenship to register or mandating citizenship-verification checks. "They're trying to appease Trump in these ways and implement his will in the states," Bedekovics said.
The calendar also limits what remains possible through ordinary channels, because judges generally disfavor major voting-law changes in the weeks before an election and early voting for the midterms begins as soon as September in some states. Election officials told The Atlantic that this is what drives fear of unprecedented moves outside the legal process, such as deploying federal agents to polling places or seizing voting machines, which Trump has said he regrets not ordering the National Guard to do in 2020. The analysis concluded that the courts had so far blocked the administration's main legal efforts and that the response of other institutions and the public would determine what happens next.
The Mail-Ballot Order and Postal Rule, July–October
Over the rest of the summer, the second order and the Postal Service rule moved through the courts together. On July 25 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit refused to pause Talwani's injunction. On August 11, in a separate case led by the League of Women Voters, Talwani issued a second injunction that barred the order's implementation in every state rather than only in the 24 jurisdictions that had sued. Ten days later, on August 21, the Postal Service published its final rule, "Ballot Mail for Federal Elections." The rule would require states to upload a list of mail and absentee voters to a USPS portal and to use unique barcodes on ballot envelopes, and it allowed noncompliant ballots to be returned to election officials rather than delivered. The Postal Service said it would not apply the rule in November unless the courts cleared the way.
On August 24 the Supreme Court ruled partly in the administration's favor, voting 6–3 to lift Talwani's June injunction in the states' case. The unsigned order held only that the challenge was premature because agencies had not yet acted, and it cautioned that whether any implementation would be lawful was something "time will tell." Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented, warning of a "Kafkaesque nightmare" for the midterms. The nationwide League of Women Voters injunction remained in force. Within days, 24 states and Washington, D.C., sued over the final postal rule, and Talwani blocked it as well. The First Circuit left her order in place, and on September 13 Judge Carl Nichols of the federal district court in Washington, D.C., a Trump appointee, issued a second injunction finding that the rule exceeded the Postal Service's authority.
When the administration sought emergency relief, the Supreme Court on September 14 declined to let the rule take effect, with only Justices Alito and Thomas noting dissents. Justice Kavanaugh wrote separately that there was a "fair prospect" the Postal Service had authority to issue such a rule, but he agreed that it could not be imposed so close to an election. The order leaves that question open for 2028: states may comply voluntarily, but the Postal Service cannot refuse to deliver ballots in November. Trump called the ruling a "big loss for Republicans." As of mid-October, Votebeat reported that the key provisions of both executive orders remained blocked, namely the postal ballot rules, the attempt to end mail-ballot grace periods, and the documentary-proof-of-citizenship requirement.
On September 28, ProPublica reporters Jen Fifield and Peter Elkind reported how the order was drafted. According to several people familiar with the discussions, the White House, which first approached the Postal Service about mail voting in the fall of 2025, initially proposed requiring that all ballots be delivered by certified mail. That would have required voters to be home to sign for their ballots and local governments to pay a higher fee for each envelope. The administration dropped the idea after Postal Service officials objected that it could not be carried out, and one top postal official told ProPublica it was "for many reasons, a terrible idea." White House spokesperson Lauren Bis disputed that the proposal was "unworkable" and said that played no part in the decision "to go in another direction."
ProPublica also reported that postal officials were then left out of key discussions and that the order's contents surprised even the agency's lawyers. The order put Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who has no formal authority over the Postal Service, in charge of coordinating its implementation, and a Commerce Department spokesperson said Lutnick had served in "an advisory and coordination capacity" in drafting it. The White House team on mail voting included J. Brian Sikma, a special presidential assistant who has worked on other administration election initiatives. When career postal officials proposed collecting state voter lists without using them to decide which ballots to deliver, the White House counsel rejected the idea as "not enough," according to a former official. The White House team also insisted that if even one envelope in a batch mailing did not match the state list, the entire mailing be rejected. Some members of the Postal Service's bipartisan Board of Governors found the order alarming but did not challenge it, sources told ProPublica, because they feared Trump would try to fire them and expected the courts to block it. Bis said the order "added important safeguards to vote-by-mail." Jonathan Smith, president of the American Postal Workers Union, said the goal was "to create chaos and doubt in the vote-by-mail process" and called the board's reliance on the courts "a dangerous calculation."
The SAVE America Act
In Congress, the administration's priority is the SAVE America Act. The measure would require documentary proof of citizenship, such as a passport or birth certificate, to register to vote in federal elections and a government-issued photo ID to cast a ballot, and it would direct states to share registration data with DHS for citizenship checks. On February 11, 2026, the House passed the bill 218–213, almost entirely along party lines, with Texas Rep. Henry Cuellar the only Democrat in support. It was the third straight year the House has approved a version of the bill.
Noncitizen voting in federal elections has been a federal crime since 1996, and registration forms already require applicants to swear to their citizenship under penalty of perjury. Critics say the documentary-proof requirement would effectively end mail and online registration and burden eligible voters. The Brennan Center estimates that more than 21 million voting-age citizens lack ready access to proof of citizenship. A Bipartisan Policy Center analysis found that 9 percent of eligible voters lack easy access to such documents and that 52 percent of registered voters do not have a passport matching their current legal name, a particular concern for married women who have changed their names. Legal scholars add that the Supreme Court held in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council (2013) that voter qualifications are set by the states, not Congress.
In the Senate, the bill faces a filibuster, and Majority Leader John Thune has said it lacks the votes. Beyond the Democrats, five Republican senators have opposed it: Lisa Murkowski, Susan Collins, Thom Tillis, Bill Cassidy and Mitch McConnell. Several of them object to its near-ban on mail ballots. Trump has pressed Senate Republicans to end the filibuster to pass the bill, which they have declined to do. On June 24 he withheld his signature from a bipartisan housing bill, which had passed by veto-proof margins, until the Senate acts, a move several Republicans called counterproductive. The Atlantic reported in early July that Trump had dismissed the housing bill as a "yawn" compared with election legislation and had encouraged Congress to block other measures, including national-security legislation, unless the SAVE America Act, which he has deemed a "National Emergency," was attached. According to the magazine, the dispute had left Congress gridlocked over the annual defense-spending bill, with shouting matches and disagreements over strategy between the president and Republican lawmakers.
The Senate took up the issue in August. Under a deal between Thune and Trump, senators voted in the early hours of August 8 on a pared-down version from Sen. Jon Husted of Ohio that kept only the photo-ID requirement. It failed to advance, with 52 Republicans in favor, eight short of the 60 needed, and no Democratic votes. "We're not done. We're just getting started," said Sen. Mike Lee of Utah. GOP leaders promised a vote on the full bill when the Senate returned in September, but Thune has continued to say Republicans lack the votes to end the filibuster, and the measure will not become law before the midterms. Votebeat noted that even the bill's failure could let the administration argue the 2026 results were tainted. In the same session, the Senate confirmed Todd Blanche as attorney general by a 50–49 vote. Blanche, Trump's former personal defense lawyer, had served as acting attorney general since Pam Bondi was removed from the post in April.
Federal Grant Money for Voter Registration
The administration has also proposed limiting federal support for voter registration. A May 29, 2026 proposed rule from the Office of Management and Budget, part of a broader rewrite of federal grant rules, would bar recipients from using federal grant money for "a voter registration campaign, voter registration drive, or any similar activity." ProPublica reported that the ban would reach the 57 nonprofits that Congress funds under the Help America Vote Act to help people with disabilities register and vote, and that it could conflict with the National Voter Registration Act, which requires some grant-funded public-assistance programs to offer registration. OMB did not respond to ProPublica's questions. A stopgap spending bill signed in September bars OMB from finalizing the rule through December 11, 2026, so it cannot apply to the midterms. The rule is covered in a separate entry.
Demanding State Voter Rolls
Since May 2025, the Justice Department has demanded unredacted voter rolls from at least 44 states and Washington, D.C., including voters' driver's-license numbers and partial Social Security numbers. When most states refused or offered only the publicly available versions of their lists, the department began suing, and by spring 2026 it had filed suit against roughly 30 states, nine of them led by Republicans. The department also offered states confidential agreements under which the federal government would flag voters for removal. Eileen O'Connor, a former attorney in the department's Voting Section, told Stateline that the aim is a national database of every voter. The resistance has crossed party lines: West Virginia's Republican secretary of state, Kris Warner, a Trump ally, said he had campaigned against federal overreach and never expected to be fighting the department over his own state's files.
Courts have repeatedly ruled against the department. Federal judges in California, Michigan and Oregon dismissed the cases, and the California court warned against "the centralization of Americans' information within the Executive Branch." The Michigan dismissal, issued by U.S. District Judge Hala Y. Jarbou, a Trump appointee, became the first of the cases to reach an appeals court. On June 24, 2026, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed it, ruling 2–1 against the Justice Department in its effort to force Michigan to turn over unredacted voter data, including dates of birth, partial Social Security numbers and driver's-license numbers. Judge Andre Mathis, a Biden appointee joined by Senior Judge R. Guy Cole Jr., a Clinton appointee, wrote for the majority that the 1960 Civil Rights Act the department had invoked did not require states to hand over a statewide voter list. He added that the government was using a law meant to protect voting rights "for an inverse purpose—to ensure that some people have not voted." Judge John Nalbandian, appointed by Trump during his first term, dissented. Democracy Docket noted that the decision was the first appeals-court ruling against the department, following nine consecutive district-court rulings against it, and that it set up a possible path to the Supreme Court.
District courts continued to rule against the department in July, including judges Trump appointed. In a ruling blocking the department's effort to obtain Pennsylvania's voter data, Chief Judge Cathy Bissoon of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania wrote that the administration's "efforts have been rebuked by every court to consider them," noting that ten courts had already blocked similar demands in other states. In a footnote, she added that the demands "have yielded one unexpected benefit, namely, bipartisan agreement. Five of the district judges are Trump appointees." One of them, Judge Stephanie Gallagher, a 2019 Trump nominee, dismissed the department's suit against Maryland, writing that "the Court joins every court to have addressed this issue" in holding that states cannot be compelled to hand over unredacted voter files. Not every state has declined, however. The Atlantic reported that at least 10 states had voluntarily given the Justice Department the personal information of millions of voters.
On August 14, the full Sixth Circuit declined to rehear the Michigan case, which left the panel's ruling in place as binding precedent. By mid-October, a ProPublica tracker counted 30 states plus Washington, D.C., that the department had sued. Of those cases, the department had lost all 26 that reached a final ruling, which were decided by eight Trump appointees, four George W. Bush appointees and 14 Democratic appointees. Four cases were still pending, and one state had settled.
A separate case, brought against the department by the advocacy group Common Cause, produced a broader ruling on October 9. In a 78-page decision, U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan of the District of Columbia held unlawful the department's practice of collecting state voter rolls, running them through SAVE, the federal citizenship-verification system described below, and flagging voters for removal. Congress, she wrote, has left that authority "with the states." According to the ACLU, the ruling "vacates a policy that has removed United States citizens from the voter rolls." By the time of the decision, 18 states, most of them led by Republicans, had complied with the department's demands. The department said it was reviewing the decision.
Some officials who declined the demands have come under federal scrutiny. Utah's Republican lieutenant governor, Deidre Henderson, had refused to hand over voters' Social Security, birth-date and driver's-license numbers, and in September the Justice Department told her in writing that she was under investigation. Henderson told 60 Minutes that Utah's own review had found 52 questionable registrations among more than 2 million voters.
Bondi's Letter to Minnesota
The data demands have at times been linked to federal immigration enforcement. On January 25, 2026, the same day a Border Patrol agent shot and killed a U.S. citizen during immigration operations in Minneapolis, Attorney General Pam Bondi sent Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz a letter demanding several concessions to "restore the rule of law," including handing over the state's voter rolls. State officials read the letter as making relief from the federal immigration operations conditional on the data. Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon called it an attempt to coerce the state and "an apparent ransom," and Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes likened it to organized crime. At a later hearing, the presiding judge said the letter suggested a "quid pro quo." Richard Hasen, an election-law professor at UCLA, called the letter reprehensible and said it showed that immigration enforcement was being used to pressure Democratic-led states.
The SAVE Citizenship-Verification System
The administration's main tool for identifying noncitizen voters has produced errors of its own. At Trump's direction, the Department of Homeland Security spent 2025 expanding SAVE, a system once used mainly to check immigrants' eligibility for public benefits, into a tool that lets states verify voters' citizenship in bulk. The March 2025 executive order gave states free access to the system and gave U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) 30 days to work with DOGE to incorporate closely held Social Security Administration data. David Jennings, a USCIS deputy, told a call hosted by Cleta Mitchell's Election Integrity Network that his team had tested and deployed the expansion in two weeks.
A ProPublica–Texas Tribune investigation found that DHS put the tool into use before it could reliably determine a person's current citizenship. The result was persistent errors, particularly for people born abroad, who often receive Social Security numbers years before they naturalize, and DHS had to send corrected results to at least five states. In Boone County, Missouri, clerk Brianna Lennon found that more than half of the 74 voters SAVE flagged were citizens, including a man her own staff had registered at his naturalization ceremony. Brian Broderick, who runs the USCIS verification division, acknowledged that the system cannot always find the most current citizenship information but said it was up to states how to use the data, and he denied that the rollout was reckless. He also acknowledged that voters flagged by SAVE are referred to DHS for possible criminal investigation.
The bulk searches identified few potential noncitizens, and many of those identifications were wrong. In at least seven states that reported results, with about 35 million registered voters combined, SAVE flagged roughly 4,200 people, or about 0.01 percent, as potential noncitizens, a rate consistent with earlier findings that noncitizens rarely register. Texas ran more than 18 million voters through the system and flagged 2,724 of them; at least 87 of those flagged, in 29 counties, were confirmed citizens, and more than 5 percent of the flagged voters who were checked turned out to be citizens. Missouri directed local clerks to make flagged voters temporarily unable to cast ballots before the findings were confirmed. After corrections, St. Louis County's list of 691 flagged voters fell to 133, and Boone County's list of 74 fell to 33.
Local officials and advocacy groups have objected to how the system is used. About 70 Missouri clerks from both parties wrote to the state House speaker urging better methods, and Lennon said she would not remove voters from the rolls based on the tool's results because it is "not ready for prime time." In March, voting-rights groups sued Texas over its use of the system, arguing that it discriminates against naturalized citizens.
Federal courts have since ruled on the expanded system itself. In one of several late-June and early-July rulings against the administration's election program, a federal judge barred use of the modified SAVE system, which had added Social Security records and other data on native-born Americans to what was once a database focused on noncitizens. The judge wrote that the system "knowingly trampled on the privacy rights of American citizens in a manner that threatens the sacred right to vote." The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit declined to pause that ruling, but on September 25 the Supreme Court stayed the injunction while the appeal proceeds, allowing the modified system back into use. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, dissented, writing that "the harm caused by burdening or disenfranchising even a few lawful voters outweighs" any harm to the government. DHS says election officials in 25 states, most of them led by Republicans, have run their rolls through SAVE. Because federal law bars the systematic removal of voters from the rolls in the 90 days before a federal election, mass removals are not expected before November 3, although officials can still check individual voters, and bulk screening can resume after the election.
Federal Law Enforcement and Local Election Offices
The Fulton County Search and the FBI Investigation
On January 28, 2026, the FBI raided the election hub of Fulton County, Georgia, and seized more than 650 boxes of 2020 ballots, tabulator tapes and voter rolls. According to ProPublica, the operation was driven by Kurt Olsen, Trump's new director of election security and integrity, a lawyer who worked to overturn the 2020 result in court and whom judges later sanctioned over unfounded allegations he made in Arizona. Olsen flew to Georgia to press Paul Brown, head of the FBI's Atlanta field office, to seize the ballots, and gave him a report assembled by a longtime ally with a history of discredited claims. After Brown's team concluded that the case was not strong enough, Brown was told to retire or relocate, and he retired. The raid went forward under his replacement, and the prosecution was assigned to a Missouri-based U.S. attorney working well outside his own jurisdiction. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard joined the search and connected the agents by phone to Trump, although the warrant did not allege foreign interference.
An NPR review found that the FBI's supporting affidavit omitted key findings from earlier Georgia investigations. Among them was a 2024 conclusion that the issues "do not affect the accuracy of the results of the 2020 General Election in Fulton County," which had been confirmed by audit and recount. Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger is the Republican who, on a recorded call on January 2, 2021, rebuffed Trump's demand to "find 11,780 votes", one more than Biden's certified margin of victory in the state. He criticized the new probe as an attempt to "change the past with baseless and repackaged claims."
Others raised concerns about the seizure itself. Wendy Weiser of the Brennan Center for Justice called the raid unprecedented, saying she knew of no other instance in which the federal government had confiscated original state election records, and warned that it could be "a practice run" for gaining access to machines or ballots during a future election. The NAACP asked a federal judge to bar the government from using the seized voter data for any purpose beyond the criminal case. Former lawyers in the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section told ProPublica that they likely would have blocked the investigation had the unit still been intact. In February, Judge Robert C.I. McBurney of the Fulton County Superior Court noted his own unease in a brief ruling: "We are left to hope that the bureau and the Department of Justice handle the ballots and related records with the care required to preserve and protect their integrity."
For months afterward, the investigation showed little public activity. The raid produced no criminal charges, and the bureau offered no update. In May, the Justice Department demanded the identities of every worker who had staffed Fulton County's 2020 election, but the county moved to quash the demand, and a judge temporarily blocked it while the litigation continues. Then, on July 2, the New York Times reported, based on an internal FBI memo, that Director Kash Patel had designated the Georgia probe a "priority" and that the bureau was assigning 260 investigative analysts from field offices across the country to the case. According to the memo, the analysts would complete "approximately 708 records checks" by a July 17 deadline, with overtime "including weekends and holidays" authorized and training provided by the Atlanta field office. Typical federal cases add five to ten analysts, and a former senior FBI official told the Times they could not recall a surge of that size outside a sustained command post for an event such as an inauguration or a terrorist attack.
The deployment drew criticism. Fulton County Commission Chair Robb Pitts called it a "Hail Mary" to keep what he described as a sham investigation alive, noting that the bureau had held the documents since the night of the raid. Sen. Mark Warner of Virginia, the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, said the reports "raise serious questions about whether the F.B.I. is diverting extraordinary resources to pursue claims about the 2020 election that have already been repeatedly examined and rejected." He warned that "politicizing federal law enforcement in service of relitigating a settled election" risks "casting a shadow over the integrity of the 2026 elections before a single vote is cast." Rep. Nikema Williams, a Democrat who represents Atlanta, called the surge "another troubling sign of a pattern in this administration to attempt to toss out, overturn, or cast doubt on election results that do not fit partisan narratives," and Senate Democrats began to examine the deployment. Raffensperger, for his part, said that "Georgia runs the most secure elections in the nation" and that his office stood ready to assist any investigation that would reassure Georgians their votes are counted accurately.
The July 17 deadline passed without any public result. Asked at a September 15 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing whether the probe had produced indictments, Patel said only that "that matter is ongoing." On October 18, 60 Minutes reported that "nothing has come of the investigation." Fulton County Commissioner Dana Barrett, who called the seizure "political theater aimed at undermining the 2026 and 2028 elections," said she did not know where the county's seized ballots were.
On October 2, The Atlantic published an account of the FBI's election work by reporter Sarah Fitzpatrick, based on interviews with more than 40 current and former administration officials, FBI employees, members of Congress and others, most of whom spoke anonymously. Officials told the magazine that Patel had been briefed on "election integrity" investigations in Arizona, Florida, New Jersey, Ohio and elsewhere, and that many of the requests came directly from the White House with messages such as "this is a push from 47." According to three people familiar with the meetings, Patel expressed frustration that the inquiries had produced no new findings and told staff to "look harder" or "look again." Employees who took part in the July Fulton County surge said they were told to compare the county's voting records against another database, a process they described as prone to errors and below FBI standards, and that it did not yield anything substantive. Two analysts who raised questions about the process were escorted out of the office. Officials also said the most heavily staffed election-related inquiry, run by the U.S. attorney's office in South Florida, had "yielded little to nothing."
Patel did not answer the magazine's 17 written questions and replied instead with a remark about a "gold-plated jet ski." An FBI spokesperson said that "election security is and will continue to be one of this FBI's highest national security priorities," cited a "500% increase in election integrity related investigations and arrests just this year alone," and denied that any internal concerns had been raised; five other FBI officials issued statements calling the reporting "false." Asked about the removed analysts, the FBI said individuals are removed only if they "engage in weaponization of law enforcement, act unethically, or undermine the FBI mission." A White House spokesperson said that "the claim that the White House dictates who the Department investigates or charges is false." Patel is suing The Atlantic and Fitzpatrick for $250 million over her April reporting on his conduct as director.
The Director of National Intelligence and the 2020 Election
Trump has also sought to involve the intelligence community in reexamining the 2020 election. After Gabbard left the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Trump instructed his new acting director of national intelligence, Bill Pulte, to find and disclose evidence that he actually won the 2020 election. As director, Pulte would have access to essentially all of the classified information in the government's possession, as well as the authority to selectively declassify reports. Lawmakers feared he could use that combination to release an incomplete or misleading account of 2020 and to undermine public confidence in the fairness of the midterms, a concern similar to the one Warner raised about the FBI's Fulton County surge. Pulte's tenure was brief. Trump nominated Jay Clayton, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, to hold the post permanently. At his July 15 confirmation hearing, Clayton declined to say directly who won the 2020 election, a refusal that cost him Democratic support, and on July 28 the Senate confirmed him as director of national intelligence by a party-line vote of 51–47.
The Debate Over Georgia's Voting Machines
Georgia has also become the center of a debate over voting equipment. Several key Georgia Republicans, echoing Trump's opposition to voting machines, have pushed to replace the state's touchscreen ballot-marking devices with hand-marked paper ballots, and a draft emergency order from Trump's allies would mandate hand-marked, hand-counted paper ballots nationwide. State Election Board member Carolyn Roddy has defended the effort to eliminate touchscreens: "It's the opportunity for manipulation... that we're trying to protect against."
In July, Raffensperger argued that the evidence favors the touchscreens. A statewide audit of all 1.11 million ballots cast in Georgia's June 2026 runoff elections found 23 discrepancies, every one of them traced to hand-marked absentee or provisional ballots, while the 1,079,408 ballots completed on touchscreen devices produced none. "Human beings make human errors. The likelihood of a discrepancy... is greatest when that ballot has been marked by hand," Raffensperger said, adding, "We run elections with nearly perfect accuracy." He noted that at the error rate for hand-marked ballots, a presidential election with 5 million ballots would be expected to produce roughly 3,500 discrepancies. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution noted that the debate is taking place as the administration presses states to change their election practices and as the Justice Department seeks Georgia's voter registration lists.
Federal Requests to Local Election Offices, State by State
A second Reuters investigation, published April 27, 2026, as part of a body of work that won the news agency a Pulitzer Prize for national reporting, found that the administration has gone beyond cutting federal capacity and has begun reaching directly into local election administration in at least eight states. Reporters documented federal officials demanding confidential voter records, seeking access to voting equipment and reviving fraud cases that courts and bipartisan reviews had already rejected. Rather than attempting a single nationwide takeover, Reuters concluded, the administration appears to be testing constitutional limits one state and one county at a time, in a field that states and localities have run since 1789.
Part of that effort has involved Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), a unit of DHS, which has pursued election-fraud inquiries, a role traditionally left to the FBI and the Justice Department. In Ohio, a newly competitive Senate battleground, HSI agents obtained voter records from at least six counties. They included heavily Democratic Franklin County, home to Columbus, where an agent collected unredacted data for at least 50 voters, including signatures, addresses and partial Social Security numbers, and pressed for information about a local voter-registration group. In Dayton, three agents visited a vocational high school to follow up on an uncorroborated, two-year-old claim about a registration drive. The school's superintendent, David Lawrence, said he was incredulous and was told that fraud allegations were now a priority. A. Scott Brown, a retired HSI supervisor, questioned what such work displaces, asking whether it pulls agents away from cases involving exploited children or fentanyl smuggling. DHS said its agents are "actively rooting out and investigating election fraud wherever it can be found."
HSI's interest in registration groups went well beyond Ohio. On October 7, 2026, the legal nonprofit Democracy Forward released internal HSI "election integrity" reports from May and June that it had obtained through a public-records request. States Newsroom reported that a June 1 report counted 82 nongovernmental organizations reviewed in Pennsylvania alone, and that groups in Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey and Ohio were also examined. Democracy Docket, whose founder Marc Elias chairs Democracy Forward's board, described the total as hundreds of groups. According to Democracy Docket, HSI found the organizations through nonprofit search engines and then checked other databases for "derogatory information." The same June 1 report said research on about 41 New Jersey organizations found "no derogatory information," and a review of 20 funds linked to a Washington, D.C., charitable foundation also found nothing. It flagged the Pennsylvania chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) for "further investigation," and Democracy Docket reported that the clothing retailer Zumiez, which has partnered with Rock the Vote and Voto Latino on youth registration drives, was flagged as well. Education Minnesota, a teachers' union, was among 22 groups HSI was beginning to research; its president, Monica Byron, said the union learned of the inquiry from Democracy Forward. CAIR Pennsylvania's executive director said its program "follows all applicable voter registration rules and requirements." The reports do not say that any group registered ineligible voters.
The reports also discussed using undercover agents. The June 1 report said the goal was to find "opportunities to leverage UC (undercover) resources," and a passage quoted by Democracy Docket said agents might "engage in communications" with targeted groups to support prosecutions. The records do not show that any undercover operation took place. In Ohio, Democracy Docket reported, HSI and the FBI were investigating seven companies that handled canvassing data for Black Fork Strategies, a voter-engagement firm founded by Kirk Noden. Noden also founded the Ohio Organizing Collaborative, a Cleveland voter-registration group whose office FBI agents searched on June 11, seizing documents and computer files. The Justice Department declined to comment on that search. The HSI reports further show that Heather Honey, the DHS election official described above, obtained 48.4 million records through "independent sources of information" and that HSI drew on about 50.6 million records from the Justice Department. The reports do not describe what those records contain. In a statement to States Newsroom, DHS declined to discuss "active investigations, investigative methods, or internal deliberations" and said that "aliens can and do vote in our elections." Hart Wood, senior oversight counsel at Democracy Forward, said the documents showed the administration pursuing "baseless claims of widespread election fraud."
The requests have also unsettled Republican officials in strongly Republican jurisdictions. In Colorado, Jeff Small, a White House–linked lobbyist and former chief of staff to Rep. Lauren Boebert, called at least 10 Republican county clerks in summer 2025 to raise the idea of "partnerships" with the White House. A follow-up caller who identified himself as a CISA official then sought access to El Paso County's Dominion voting machines, and the county's Republican clerk refused, citing state law. (DHS said Small held no role at the department.) In Missouri, a senior official in the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division sought access to Dominion equipment from at least two clerks, who declined. After Missouri ran its rolls through federal citizenship screening, clerks in St. Louis, St. Charles and smaller counties found that most of the people flagged were citizens, many of them naturalized. One Republican clerk, Clinton Jenkins, said names with "too many vowels" seemed to trigger the list. Jenkins also said that about 15 Missouri election officials had resigned over 14 months, citing stress, a pace he called unprecedented.
Reuters documented similar federal activity in other states. In Nevada, the FBI sought 2020 voter data that did not exist before closing its probe, and Democratic Secretary of State Cisco Aguilar said the episode still left his staff afraid. In Arizona, the FBI subpoenaed the state Senate's 2020 audit records, and HSI sought the files from the previous attorney general's fraud investigation. In Connecticut, a Justice Department official directed the state to investigate complaints from a group with a history of unfounded claims. In Michigan, the department's April demand for Wayne County's 2024 records was refused.
Election officials told Reuters that the cumulative effect has been intimidation and uncertainty. Administrators described training staff to recognize federal credentials and subpoenas and consulting attorneys, and one Colorado county keeps a glass-breaking tool at its windows in case of evacuation. In Williamson County, Texas, a nonpartisan administrator needed police protection after a doctored video drew death threats. Many of the individual inquiries were refused or quietly closed, and officials of both parties pushed back. Experts said, however, that the documented willingness to deploy federal law enforcement against local election offices makes November's margins consequential. Hasen cautioned that subversion is not inevitable but becomes more likely "if the election turns on a few jurisdictions" with disputed results.
Hegseth's Testimony on Troops at Polling Places
The prospect of federal troops at polling places came up directly in late April, during congressional testimony by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. At an April 29 House Armed Services Committee hearing, Rep. Jill Tokuda (D-HI) asked whether he would carry out a hypothetical order from Trump to send troops to polling places during the midterms, an act that she noted federal law (18 U.S.C. § 593) bars except when necessary to repel armed enemies of the United States. Hegseth said he rejected the premise that Trump would issue unlawful orders. He then asserted under oath that troops had been deployed to polling locations in 15 states under Biden in 2024, and he repeated the claim for emphasis. The next day, he made the same assertion in sworn testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee, where Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) challenged it.
A CNN fact-check by Daniel Dale found the claim false on multiple counts. Any National Guard support connected to the 2024 election was ordered by state governors, not the president, and every state that responded to CNN said none of its personnel had been stationed at polling places. Guard members instead worked out of public view on election cybersecurity or as liaisons, or their states' Guard units were not activated at all. A spokesperson for Iowa's Guard said its personnel assist with cybersecurity from the state emergency operations center, "in a basement," and have never gone to a polling station. Arizona's Guard said it had placed two cyber personnel on standby who were never called upon, and it sent no one to polling sites. The Pentagon declined to comment. The only recent election in which some states placed Guard troops at polling places was in 2020, during Trump's first term, when out-of-uniform personnel filled staffing gaps caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Trump has not announced plans to send troops to the polls. Hegseth's testimony was therefore false: the deployments he described under Biden did not happen. At the same hearing, he declined to rule out a future deployment that federal law forbids.
Part IV — Toward November
Calls to "Nationalize" the Vote
Trump has said publicly that he wants the federal government to take control of how elections are run. On conservative commentator Dan Bongino's show, he urged Republicans to "take over the voting" in at least 15 places and to "nationalize" elections, and in a social media post he described the states as "merely an 'agent'" that must do what the federal government directs. Members of his Cabinet have made similar statements. At a February press conference, then–DHS Secretary Kristi Noem said the department had been "proactive to make sure we have the right people voting," a remark that border czar Tom Homan declined to defend. That same month, at a February 13 rally at Fort Bragg, Trump told uniformed troops to "vote for us" in the midterms and shared the stage with a Senate candidate, although Defense Department rules bar partisan activity by active-duty service members. Most of the troops did not react.
The July 2026 Primetime Address
The Declassified Files and Trump's Claims
On the evening of July 16, 2026, Trump delivered a primetime address to the nation on what the White House billed as election integrity. The speech came four months before the midterms, a week after he moved against the Election Assistance Commission, and the night before the FBI's self-imposed deadline in its revived Fulton County inquiry. Beforehand, press secretary Karoline Leavitt had promised the material would "shock you" and be "backed by facts and by evidence." After opening on crime, the border and the economy, Trump turned to 2020. Pointing to dozens of declassified intelligence reports that were posted to whitehouse.gov as he spoke, he asserted that China had "compromised" some 220 million voter-registration files between 2020 and 2023 and had interfered in the election. He called the situation a "crisis," said "deep state" officials had concealed the evidence from him during his first term, and promised "swift" action in the days ahead. He stopped short, however, of alleging that any votes had been changed or any result altered.
The Intelligence Community Assessment: Russia, Not China
Voter-registration data of the kind Trump described is largely public and commercially available, and access to it does not allow anyone to alter a ballot. Trump presented no proof that any votes had been switched, and the declassified reports contradicted his account of Chinese interference. The intelligence community's March 2021 assessment, Foreign Threats to the 2020 US Federal Elections, opens with the finding that there were "no indications that any foreign actor attempted to alter any technical aspect of the voting process in the 2020 US elections, including voter registration, casting ballots, vote tabulation, or reporting results." The documents describe influence operations, such as propaganda and the use of proxies, rather than interference with ballots or machines, and they identify Russia as the principal actor. According to the assessment, Moscow, on Vladimir Putin's authorization, was "using a range of measures to denigrate former Vice President Biden," while Kremlin-linked actors sought "to boost President Trump's candidacy." As The Atlantic noted, those efforts included circulating claims that mail-in voting was fraudulent and that primaries were "rigged," narratives Trump himself later promoted. A comparison chart released by the White House judged only Russia to have been "observed" targeting election processes and described China and Iran as having taken only preliminary steps.
The China memo Trump highlighted said Beijing had taken "low level exploratory steps to undermine" Trump, with the aim of hurting him rather than helping Biden. Its authors noted in the next sentence that this was a minority view that "differs from the IC's judgment that Beijing has considered but not deployed influence efforts," and elsewhere the assessment stated that the intelligence community "has seen no evidence that Beijing is engaged in an effort to influence the outcome of the presidential election." Trump did not mention another released document, which described efforts by Turkey to "covertly influence" US politicians' thinking about the race.
The Venezuela Memo
The other central document concerned Venezuela, the source of the long-running claim that Dominion and Smartmatic voting machines were built to flip votes. The White House's release, a "Summary of Select Intelligence Reporting from 2004–2020 on Venezuela's Electronic Voting Manipulation Capabilities", did not support that claim. It found that the intelligence "did not definitively confirm that large-scale electronic fraud was successfully executed in specific Venezuelan elections," that the CIA's "baseline assessments" held "other factors better explained electoral outcomes," and that the reporting came from "limited sourcing." The government, in other words, could not confirm that Venezuela had rigged even its own elections, let alone any in the United States. A related 2006 assessment, CNN noted, had found that Venezuela and Smartmatic could not "manipulate the outcome of elections outside Venezuela" and that manipulating Venezuela's own elections required "insider access" to the machines, a level of access no foreign actor has to American elections.
The Noncitizen and Voting-Machine Claims
The speech's main domestic figure came from DHS. The White House said the department had found roughly 250,000 noncitizens registered to vote across four states (California, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Nevada) using commercial databases. A more reliable DHS method, checking registrations against government citizenship records through the department's SAVE system, had identified about 28,000 across 25 states. As described below, when the four states asked for the underlying names, the figures DHS provided were far smaller.
Trump also repeated claims that voting machines could be hacked. Reviews of voting equipment have repeatedly found vulnerabilities but no evidence that any were exploited in 2020. An assessment commissioned by Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, which examined machines seized from Puerto Rico, a territory that does not vote in federal elections, also found no vote-flipping. Chris Krebs, who led the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) in Trump's first term, was fired by Trump in November 2020, days after his agency called the election the most secure in American history, and he later described claims of machine manipulation as "wild and baseless." In an April 2025 executive order, Trump revoked Krebs's security clearance and ordered him investigated.
John Solomon and the Sourcing
Much of the raw material for the address was assembled by John Solomon, a conservative writer brought into the White House as a special government employee to identify documents for declassification. For nearly a decade Solomon has been a leading promoter of narratives embraced by Trump's supporters, including claims about Uranium One, the campaign against Marie Yovanovitch, then the US ambassador to Ukraine, that preceded Trump's first impeachment, and allegations of fraud in the 2020 election. Many of those claims were not substantiated. Solomon has acknowledged that his declassification work is also meant to aid a Justice Department grand jury pursuing people Trump regards as his enemies. Some pro-Trump outlets were wary of his role: the blog Conservative Treehouse added a "caution" note to its preview of the speech because Solomon was "responsible for the content." After the speech, Solomon acknowledged that no votes had been changed in the 2020, 2022 or 2024 elections and that there was no intelligence showing Venezuela had tampered with US voting machines. Asked whether the 2020 results showing that Biden won were accurate, he said, "I'm researching."
Three months after the address, the White House task force Solomon leads, which Trump had charged with uncovering election fraud, had produced no evidence of fraud, the Washington Post reported on October 17. The task force had instead released 113 documents, totaling 832 pages, from earlier investigations of Trump, including Robert Mueller's Russia inquiry and Jack Smith's classified-documents case. Trump allies regard those records as useful to a Justice Department grand jury in Florida that is examining officials who investigated him; that inquiry has issued subpoenas but no indictments, and its prosecutor, Joseph diGenova, resigned in September. Solomon told the Post his goal was "to be a neutral arbiter of releasing information to the public" and said the task force does not coordinate with the prosecutors. Legal experts and former law enforcement officials told the Post that the released records showed investigators following normal, court-authorized procedures.
Reactions
Within Trump's own party, several Republicans had feared that a renewed focus on fraud would hurt them in November and were reported to be bracing for the address. Georgia's Democratic senators, Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock, whose 2020–21 victories some in Trump's circle had suggested he would declare illegitimate, said Trump was "afraid to lose the midterms." Warnock, noting that Georgia's congressional delegation is majority Republican, questioned how "the same ballots that elected my Republican colleagues" could be legitimate while the ones that elected him and Ossoff were not. The White House, which had said the speech would not focus on Georgia, called Ossoff a "total phony."
Election experts had expected little new information, and the release largely matched that expectation. "I expect most of this to be just declassified versions of stuff we already knew publicly," David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation and Research had told the Christian Science Monitor before the speech. Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes, who reviewed the released files, said, "I have seen zero new facts. I have seen zero evidence backing any of these claims," and called the release "a repackaged version of all of the stuff that we've known for years." The Atlantic's Tom Nichols, after his own review of the files, concluded that they "actually undermine and refute" Trump's charges, and wrote that for all the foreign adversaries who seek to erode confidence in American elections, "no regime, no spies, no saboteurs have yet matched the damage that America's own president did" that night. Asked why Trump could not accept a 2024 result that his own team called secure, Leavitt said that 2024 "was too big to rig."
The Noncitizen Lists, Tested
The day after the address, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who had succeeded Noem earlier in the year, sent letters to the secretaries of state of the four states named in the speech. The letters said there "may be as many as" 190,832 noncitizens on California's rolls, 35,152 on New Jersey's, 15,903 on Nevada's and 14,576 on Pennsylvania's, and they threatened officials who failed to act with penalties up to prison. Because DHS produced the figures by matching public voter files against its immigration records, they were claims about registration, not about voting. When the states asked for the names behind the figures, DHS's responses allowed those claims to be checked directly.
Nevada: 15,903 Claimed, 185 Case Numbers Provided
Nevada Secretary of State Francisco "Cisco" Aguilar disputed the figure immediately and asked DHS for the data behind it. During an August call with state officials, a DHS official described the 15,903 figure as "the ceiling" and acknowledged that each name still needed manual review, according to a recording NPR obtained through a public-records request and reported on. A day after the call, DHS sent Nevada a spreadsheet of just 185 voter case numbers that it said it was confident belonged to noncitizens. The spreadsheet contained no names, birth dates or addresses, and DHS declined to share the data it had used to make the matches. The department said more than 14,000 other Nevada voters still needed "additional review." After the call, DHS official Kimberley Vogt wrote to Nevada officials that "we did not reduce the 15,903 to 185," explaining that DHS had manually reviewed only some of the 15,903 and had confirmed 185 as noncitizens, the New York Times reported. DHS also sent Nevada a batch of 6,218 voter case numbers that it said had "the highest number of matching attributes" to noncitizens in its records, and it said the smaller batch was sent at Nevada's request. Nevada disputed that it had made such a request, and records the Times reviewed did not show one. In a September 9 letter, DHS again told Nevada to review each of the 15,903 registrants, although Nevada said DHS had never given it a list of 15,903 people.
State officials checked the 185 case numbers against Nevada's registration records, including the identification each voter had provided when registering. In a September letter to DHS, Nevada Deputy Attorney General Greg Ott wrote that "our records indicate that they were citizens" and that DHS had "provided nothing of substance to suggest otherwise." The state noted that it could not be absolutely certain without the identifying information DHS had refused to provide. Case numbers are administrative identifiers that may have been duplicated when Nevada moved to a new voter-registration system, so the state and DHS might not even have been looking at the same people. DHS's submission did not identify any noncitizen voter. "Repeating unsupported claims does not make them true," Aguilar said. DHS called Nevada's characterization false and said the 185 were "simply a subset" of the records it had reviewed, but it did not explain why it had publicized a number its own staff called a ceiling. Pennsylvania officials held a similar call with DHS but never received a narrowed list, and a state official said DHS did not appear confident in its own numbers.
The dispute was still unresolved in October. Trump had cited the Nevada figure himself, telling the nation in his July address that about 16,000 noncitizens were registered to vote there. In an October 7 interview with TIME, Aguilar, a Democrat seeking reelection this year, said every one of the 185 voters was a U.S. citizen. He added that he could not say with certainty that no noncitizens were on Nevada's rolls, and that his office was still waiting for DHS data it could analyze. A DHS spokesperson told TIME that the department was "assisting Nevada by narrowing their list of nearly 2.3 million registered voters to just 15,903 who match an alien in DHS records." On October 15, Aguilar told FOX5 Las Vegas that DHS's worksheet listed about 6,400 voters, of whom DHS said it had verified 185. For each person, he said, it gave only a voter case number, a yes-or-no citizenship designation and whether DHS had researched the person. Aguilar said his office had reviewed the original registration forms for all 185 and "found that all of them were justified registered voters," and that DHS had declined in writing to provide the names, addresses or birth dates needed to confirm identities. The same day, DHS told the Vegas PBS program Nevada Week that since the 185, it had "manually confirmed about 2,000 more aliens from the same list." The figure came from a DHS statement and could not be independently checked. DHS did not answer the program's question about whether it still considered the 185 to be noncitizens. In the same statement, DHS called Nevada's claim that it lacked enough information to act "false," saying its Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate had already given the state the voter ID numbers Nevada assigns. On the program, former Republican Gov. Brian Sandoval said the state had found "zero" noncitizens out of 16,000. Nevada's review, however, covered the 185 records DHS identified, not the full 15,903, and former Democratic Assembly Speaker Richard Perkins said on the same program that he did not know how many of the 16,000 the state had investigated.
New Jersey: A Confirmed Registration Error
New Jersey is the only one of the four states where officials confirmed a registration problem, though it was smaller than the federal figure. On July 21, Gov. Mikie Sherrill disclosed that a software error in the state's motor-vehicle registration system had added about 6,600 noncitizens to the voter rolls between June 2023 and June 2024, "through no fault of their own," and that a preliminary review found up to 400 of them had voted. State officials detected and disclosed the error themselves, while IDEMIA, the contractor involved, disputes that its software was to blame. The 6,600 figure is about a fifth of the 35,152 DHS claimed, and FactCheck.org found that Trump's claim of "thousands of votes" overstated the problem. Sherrill said there was "no evidence at this time that any elections were swayed." Kamala Harris won New Jersey in 2024 by more than 252,000 votes.
California: 190,832 Claimed, 28 Charged
California received no list in July. On October 13, with ballots already in the mail, Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter of the Justice Department sent Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar Dean Logan a thumb drive containing what the department called more than 20,000 "likely noncitizen registrants." The password was written on a sticky note, and the officials were given 48 hours to set aside, but not cancel, the ballots of people on the list. Logan said his office did not consider the device a secure medium. The department also threatened to prosecute officials who counted those ballots as "aiders and abettors to a federal crime," and on October 15 it sued Weber and Logan to force California to segregate up to 20,000 ballots cast by people on the list. At first, officials did not explain how the July figure of 190,832 had become 20,000. DHS said publicly that it had "manually verified" the names, and Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, wrote that the list represented "the number of noncitizens confirmed by a review of federal databases." The department's complaint, however, said only that DHS "believes" the 20,000 are "likely" noncitizens, and that it was "not practicable or feasible for the United States to investigate before the 2026 election concludes," Democracy Docket reported. Gov. Gavin Newsom said the demand "should scare the hell out of every American."
On October 16, DHS gave its explanation in a post on X. It said the July figure had been a "preliminary universe" of California registrations that matched its immigration records and were still pending manual review, and that the roughly 20,000 were "just the subset of records manually verified so far." A Justice Department spokesperson similarly told Newsweek that the 20,000 had been "manually verified to date" and that the number "can and will go up," but did not say that manual verification meant the voters' noncitizen status had been definitively established. Aaron Reichlin-Melnick of the American Immigration Council replied to DHS that the complaint itself said only that Homeland Security Investigations "reasonably believes" that around 20,000 noncitizens are registered to vote in California, and that the Justice Department had told the court it lacked time to investigate each case. He also pointed to Nevada, where state records indicated that all 185 voters DHS had flagged were citizens.
On October 19, under what it called "Operation Protect the Vote," the Justice Department charged 28 people across California's four federal districts and arrested 11 of them. All 28 were lawful permanent residents, green-card holders who are not citizens and may not vote. According to federal prosecutors, 22 are accused of voting in at least one election, as recently as the June primary, while five are accused only of registering and one of casting a provisional ballot in 2020. McCotter said all 28 appeared on the 20,000-name list. The charges are allegations, not convictions, and cases of this kind are prosecuted in most election cycles.
The cases are small relative to the size of California's electorate. The state has about 23 million registered voters, and more than 9.4 million ballots were cast in the June primary alone, so the 28 people charged represent roughly 0.0001 percent of registrants, a rate consistent with the Brennan Center's 2016 study described earlier. California Attorney General Rob Bonta called the cases "a drop in the bucket" that showed there was no widespread fraud, and said anyone guilty should be held accountable. Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, said the arrests proved "what we have been saying," and added that about 113 noncitizens in 20 states had been charged nationally with illegal voting or registration offenses over the previous two months. A Votebeat review of the roughly 70 such cases charged by late September found no sign of organized efforts.
Officials have continued to describe the list in different terms. In an October 19 emergency motion asking the court to stop California from counting the ballots, the Justice Department described the people on the list as "highly likely to be noncitizen aliens." At a press conference the same day, McCotter acknowledged that the list could include citizens. "We're not perfect and that's why we've asked California to cooperate with us," he said, according to a Democracy Docket tally of the administration's statements. On October 20, Essayli wrote that federal authorities had "verified" that at least 20,000 noncitizens were receiving ballots. On October 21, the case was transferred to U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, and California and Los Angeles County asked him to dismiss it. They argued that the department lacks standing and that the federal criminal law barring noncitizens from voting (18 U.S.C. § 611) does not authorize a civil suit to change how states count ballots. A hearing was scheduled for October 27. On October 22, before Carter had ruled, the department filed a notice of appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. It argued that his failure to rule by a noon deadline it had requested amounted to a "constructive denial" of its request for emergency relief.
Washington, D.C.: Votes Cast Legally in Local Elections
Some of the claims that circulated in October counted legal votes as fraud. On October 15, the conservative legal group Judicial Watch reported that 578 noncitizens had voted in Washington, D.C.'s June 16, 2026, primary and special elections, citing D.C. Board of Elections records it obtained through a public-records request filed with the D.C. Republican Party. Of the 578, 510 were registered Democrats and four were Republicans. Judicial Watch president Tom Fitton called the votes "an outrage and insult to every American citizen" and urged Congress to ensure that elections in the capital "are only decided by American citizens." The conservative journalist Paul Sperry shared the figure the same day as breaking news, writing that "close to 600 foreign nationals voted in the Washington, D.C., elections in June."
The votes were legal. Federal law bars noncitizens from voting in federal elections, but states and localities may allow them to vote in local races, and a D.C. law that took effect in 2023 lets noncitizen residents vote in the city's local elections, a point Judicial Watch's release itself acknowledges. Aaron Reichlin-Melnick of the American Immigration Council responded that it was "incredibly deceptive" to share the number without explaining that the votes were cast in local elections under a law authorizing them, and noted that noncitizen voting in local elections was common in early America. When Judicial Watch made a similar claim about D.C.'s 2024 primary, the D.C. Board of Elections said that noncitizen voters had received ballots listing only local contests, with no federal offices.
The Draft Emergency Order
The address renewed attention to a proposal that had circulated outside the government since early in the year. In February 2026, the Washington Post reported that pro-Trump activists who said they were coordinating with the White House were circulating a 17-page draft executive order. The draft would declare a national emergency over elections and, on that basis, ban most mail-in ballots, mandate voter ID, require hand-marked and hand-counted paper ballots, and order voters to re-register with proof of citizenship for 2026. Its central premise, that China interfered in the 2020 election, contradicts the intelligence community assessment described above, which concluded with high confidence that China did not attempt to change the outcome and that Russia ran the main foreign influence campaign. Analysts at Democracy Docket, a legal news site focused on voting, found that the draft also cites a nonexistent provision and statutes that do not grant the powers it claims.
People associated with the effort include Florida lawyer Peter Ticktin, who said he had "certain coordination" with the White House, and the author Jerome Corsi. ABC News also reported contacts with former national security adviser Michael Flynn, MyPillow chief executive Mike Lindell and former Overstock chief executive Patrick Byrne, all of whom were involved in efforts to overturn the 2020 result. Trump said he had "never heard about it." Legal scholars across the ideological spectrum say a president has no such authority, but they also warn that an unlawful order can remain in force while it is litigated. Trump's "Liberation Day" tariffs, for example, stood for more than ten months before the Supreme Court struck them down, and an election order issued close to November could disrupt voting before the courts intervene.
"The Predicate He Needs": Bannon, Cobb and Calls for Emergency Action
Some of Trump's allies and former aides described the July address as a possible basis for such an order. Before the speech, Steve Bannon, Trump's former chief strategist, said it needed to serve as a "predicate" for a "national security emergency executive order" on elections. Ty Cobb, a lawyer in Trump's first White House, told PBS NewsHour that he read the speech the same way, as adding to "the predicate that he needs to declare an emergency at or about the time of the elections."
No such order had been issued as of mid-October, but Trump has not ruled one out. Asked in an August interview whether he might declare an election emergency, he said that "stranger things have happened." Several allies have continued to call for emergency action. Tina Peters, the former Colorado county clerk who was released from prison in June, has since traveled to Washington seven times and visited the White House at least twice to press for emergency action on voting machines. Lindell has said "the president needs to completely declare a national emergency" and ban electronic machines, and Ticktin, who is also Peters' lawyer, has suggested Trump might have to declare martial law and have federal forces seize machines where results are disputed. Cleta Mitchell, a conservative election lawyer, has urged the Commerce Department to require partial hand counts before certification. A separate Commerce Department idea, to classify voting-machine components as national-security threats, was reportedly dropped after investigators found no evidence to support it. A Brennan Center analysis published October 16 concluded that no emergency statute authorizes a president to seize voting equipment or send troops to the polls.
As Voting Begins: Federal Monitors and Agents at the Polls
Bannon has predicted that ICE agents will "surround the polls" in November, and Cobb told PBS that the presence of federal agents at polling places was "a virtual certainty." With early voting under way in October, the federal government's plans for polling places became a practical concern for election officials. On August 17, Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon, who heads the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, announced that the department would send a record 1,000 federal monitors to polling places, up from 714 in 2024 and 289 in the 2022 midterms, and that it would recruit volunteers from across the federal workforce, including U.S. attorneys' offices, to reach that number. Monitoring compliance with the Voting Rights Act is a longstanding practice, but it has traditionally been carried out by the department's voting section, which has since lost nearly all its career attorneys. Dhillon dismissed fears that the administration would try to overturn results as "paranoia."
The administration has also broken with a two-decade practice of inviting election observers from the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. On October 6, MS NOW reported that the State Department had not invited the OSCE, a regional security organization that includes the United States, to observe the midterms. OSCE observers have attended every U.S. federal election since 2002, including the 2018 midterms during Trump's first term and the 2024 election, which they described as "well-run." OSCE members have agreed to invite one another's observers, and the organization called the U.S. decision "regrettable" and said it "is not in line" with those commitments. According to MS NOW, Russia and Belarus are the only other members to have excluded OSCE observers. A State Department spokesperson said the OSCE "should focus its limited resources on elections where it can have the greatest impact." OSCE observers do not intervene and have no enforcement power; they visit some polling places, with access set by each state, and publish a report on how the election was run. The decision concerns the OSCE invitation and does not by itself bar other observers. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said it "risks undermining public trust in America's safe and secure election system." Dan Baer, who was U.S. ambassador to the OSCE under President Obama, said that refusing observers "is usually something that countries in a position of weakness do, when they know that they have corrupt or unfair elections."
Military leaders have said troops will not be involved. In an August 28 letter to Sen. Elissa Slotkin, Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, wrote that the military had no plans to send troops or federalized National Guard members to polling sites, or to seize ballots or voting machines. "I have neither received nor anticipate receiving any unlawful order concerning the role of the Joint Force in the upcoming November 2026 midterm elections," he wrote. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth did not respond to Slotkin's letter.
DHS has not offered the same assurance. Around the start of September, Mullin suggested that ICE officers could enter polling places on Election Day to arrest a suspect or to respond to reports of undocumented immigrants inside. He has also threatened to jail election officials and to withhold federal funds from states that do not adopt his department's election-security measures. A DHS spokesperson, however, said that "ICE is not planning operations targeting polling locations." Mullin has also directed agents to step up voter-fraud investigations in nine states and later directed hundreds of agents nationwide to focus on finding noncitizens on voter rolls. The FBI has likewise left the question open: at a September 15 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, FBI Director Kash Patel declined to rule out sending FBI agents to polling places.
Voting-rights groups and local governments have gone to court before Election Day to keep armed federal agents away from the polls. On September 18, the NAACP and eight other organizations sued DHS, the Justice Department and the FBI, arguing that the administration had reversed longstanding policies keeping armed federal agents out of polling places, in violation of the Voting Rights Act and a Civil War–era law barring "armed men" at the polls (18 U.S.C. § 592). The complaint cites an immigration checkpoint set up on a main road leading to a polling place in Lee County, Florida. Democratic committees and congressional leaders filed a similar suit on September 23. On October 20, Arlington County, Virginia, sued in federal court to keep armed ICE and FBI agents away from its polling sites after flyers bearing a DHS logo and a hotline for reporting voting "violations" appeared on cars in neighboring Alexandria. DHS denied involvement with the flyers. As of mid-October there had been no confirmed report of federal immigration agents at an early-voting site, but election officials in states including Wisconsin and Michigan have been training poll workers on how to respond if agents arrive.
Public Opinion
Polling shows that public views on federal involvement in elections vary by party and by the specific measure. A February Washington Post–ABC–Ipsos poll found that 54 percent of adults, including 55 percent of independents, opposed the federal government taking over election administration and vote-counting in certain states, while 23 percent supported it. An NPR/PBS/Marist survey in March 2026 found 66 percent of Americans confident that their state or local government would run a fair and accurate election in November, down from 76 percent in October 2024, with confidence falling among Democrats and independents.
Many Republicans share Trump's views on fraud. An April Reuters/Ipsos poll found that 63 percent of Republicans believe the 2020 election was stolen, compared with 9 percent of Democrats. Among Republicans, 82 percent agreed that noncitizens cast large numbers of fraudulent ballots, and 62 percent favored a federal law-enforcement presence at polling places. Voter-ID requirements drew 77 percent support across party lines. Support for deploying troops to polling places was lower, at about 28 percent overall, and Republicans themselves were roughly split on it. The same survey found that roughly 71 percent of Republicans and 79 percent of Democrats remained confident their own ballots would be counted, a confidence researchers link to turnout. The experts ProPublica interviewed worried that federal endorsement makes false claims harder to correct; as the Brennan Center's Derek Tisler put it, it is difficult to debunk such claims when they arrive "with the seal of the federal government."
Later polling found lower confidence as November approached. A UC San Diego survey of 5,016 adults, conducted September 1–9 by the university's Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections, found that 49 percent expect the midterms to be free and fair, while 23 percent said they did not and 28 percent were unsure. Since January, the share confident that votes nationwide are counted as intended had fallen from 57 to 49 percent among independents and from 65 to 58 percent among Republicans, while holding roughly steady at 63 percent among Democrats. At least a third of every partisan group expected federal immigration officers to be present at polling places in their area, and the parties differed on what that would mean: 60 percent of Democrats and 37 percent of independents said it would make them less confident in the count, while 46 percent of Republicans said it would make them more confident.