← All 148 executive actions

Trump's Budget Office Withholds and Cancels Billions Congress Appropriated

Government Jan 20, 2025
Our Analysis: Big Deal

Since January 2025, the Trump administration has held back money Congress appropriated, and the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) has run much of the effort. OMB Director Russell Vought has led it since February 2025. Agencies have paused payments, slowed grants and canceled awarded projects. The administration also asked Congress to cancel $9 billion and used two "pocket rescissions." In a pocket rescission, the president asks Congress to cancel funds so close to the end of the fiscal year that the money expires before Congress has to act. House Appropriations Democrats said in September 2025 that at least $410 billion was being held up.

The Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress's auditor, has issued nine decisions finding that agencies broke the Impoundment Control Act of 1974, two of them in part. It also found that both pocket rescissions were not allowed under the law. Lower courts ordered money released in several cases. In September 2025, however, the Supreme Court let the first pocket rescission stand on its emergency docket. It said private groups likely could not sue under the law, and it did not decide whether the tactic is legal.

Vought and OMB say the 1974 law is unconstitutional, that spending levels Congress sets are ceilings rather than requirements, and that the law's text allows pocket rescissions. Vought has told senators "We have not impounded anything" and says GAO is partisan. Congress has not changed the law. As of October 24, 2026, a seven-state lawsuit over the second pocket rescission was pending.

Details

Under the Constitution, Congress decides how federal money is spent. Since January 2025, the Trump administration has repeatedly held back money Congress approved. It has done so through executive orders, OMB memos, slow approvals of agency spending plans, grant cancellations and formal requests to cancel funds. The White House Office of Management and Budget has directed or approved much of this work. Its director, Russell Vought, a co-author of the Heritage Foundation's Project 2025, was confirmed by the Senate on a party-line vote on February 6, 2025.

This entry is the pattern-level home for those actions. Each case is summarized briefly below, with links to the entries that cover it in detail.

The Law and Vought's View of It

Congress passed the Impoundment Control Act in 1974 after President Richard Nixon refused to spend money it had appropriated, Harvard Law School professor Howell Jackson explained in an October 2026 interview. Under the law, a president may ask Congress to rescind, or cancel, funds. Congress then has 45 days to act. If it does not, the money must be released. GAO reviews each request and reports to Congress. The law also lets the comptroller general, who heads GAO, sue to force the release of withheld funds.

Vought has rejected the law. At a January 22, 2025 Senate Budget Committee hearing on his nomination, he said: "The president ran on the notion that the Impoundment Control Act is unconstitutional. I agree with that." He described the administration's early funding pauses as "programmatic delays," not impoundments. At a January 15 hearing, he told senators, "I will always commit to upholding the law," and said "200 years of presidents have used this authority."

Vought held the same job in Trump's first term. In 2019 his office froze about $214 million in security aid to Ukraine, a freeze GAO later found illegal, ProPublica's Andy Kroll reported. OMB General Counsel Mark Paoletta has argued that the 1974 law is unconstitutional and that spending laws set a ceiling, not a floor. ProPublica noted that most legal experts reject that view. Vought has said GAO "shouldn't exist," according to the same report.

The January 2025 Freeze

On January 20, 2025, Trump signed two executive orders that paused funding, according to a Mayer Brown summary. One paused payments from the Inflation Reduction Act and the 2021 infrastructure law. The other paused new foreign development aid. The first applied only to programs tied to the order's energy policies.

On January 27, OMB went further. Memo M-25-13 told agencies to pause "all activities related to obligation or disbursement of all federal financial assistance," starting the next afternoon. U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan of Washington, D.C., paused the memo for open awards minutes before it took effect. OMB withdrew the memo on January 29. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said the funding executive orders remained "in full force and effect." On January 31, Chief U.S. District Judge John McConnell of Rhode Island issued an order in a suit by 23 states and Washington, D.C. It barred agencies from freezing awards under the memo or the orders.

The effects lasted. GAO later found that from January 20 to April 15, 2025, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) paid out about $825 million less in Head Start funds than in the same period a year earlier.

Foreign Aid: A Rescission Law and the First Pocket Rescission

The largest early cuts fell on foreign aid. The administration shut down the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and canceled most of its programs. That story, including the death-toll debate, is covered in the USAID entry. Vought wanted foreign-aid spending "as close to zero as possible," ProPublica reported.

The Rescissions Act of 2025. On June 3, 2025, Trump formally asked Congress to cancel $9.4 billion. The Senate passed a reduced version 51–48 on July 17 after removing a $400 million cut to PEPFAR, the global HIV program. The House passed it 216–213 on July 18, Government Executive reported. Trump signed it on July 24. It canceled $7.9 billion in foreign aid and $1.1 billion for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Vought told reporters, "I think it's likely you'll see an additional package." Rep. Rosa DeLauro (D-Conn.), the top Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, said the administration had "stolen funds appropriated by Congress."

The first pocket rescission. On August 28, 2025, Trump sent Congress a request to cancel about $4.9 billion in foreign aid from 15 accounts. All of the money expired on September 30. The 45-day review period would not end until October 23. OMB ordered the funds withheld the next day. GAO concluded on September 12 that "the ICA does not permit the withholding of funds past their date of expiration." Paoletta responded on X: "GAO is wrong on pocket rescissions (the Impoundment Control Act text specifically allows for them)." Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), who chairs the Senate Appropriations Committee, said, "GAO has concluded that this type of rescission is unlawful and not permitted by the Impoundment Control Act." An unnamed budget official told The Fiscal Times, "Congress can choose to vote to rescind or continue the funds — it doesn't matter."

The courts. Aid groups sued in February 2025. U.S. District Judge Amir Ali of Washington, D.C., ordered payments resumed, and on March 10 he ordered appropriated aid released, according to the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse. On August 13, a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled 2–1 that the groups could not bring impoundment claims. On August 28 it amended that ruling to let them pursue claims under the Administrative Procedure Act. Ali then ordered the expiring funds made available by September 30.

On September 26, 2025, the Supreme Court paused Ali's order by a 6–3 vote, SCOTUSblog reported. The unsigned order said the administration had made a sufficient showing, "at this early stage," that the Impoundment Control Act bars the groups' suit. It said the order "should not be read as a final determination on the merits." Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, dissented. She called the case "uncharted territory" and wrote that the order would keep the funds from their recipients permanently, because the money expires. The administration said it would spend about $6.5 billion in other foreign-aid funds. The case was still open in 2026, and the government moved to dismiss it in January.

GAO Findings Across Agencies

GAO opened 39 impoundment investigations by April 2025, Comptroller General Gene Dodaro told lawmakers, ProPublica reported. After GAO's first finding, Paoletta told the Transportation Department to ignore it. GAO has issued these decisions finding violations:

Decision date Agency and program What GAO found
May 22, 2025 Transportation Department, electric-vehicle charging grants Violation. The department suspended approval of state charging plans on February 6, 2025.
June 16, 2025 Institute of Museum and Library Services Violation. The agency ended about 1,200 grants after a March 2025 executive order told it to shrink.
July 23, 2025 HHS, Head Start Violation. Payments ran about $825 million behind the prior year.
July 31, 2025 Energy Department, Renew America's Schools Violation for 2025 funds, delayed for policy review. No violation for earlier years.
August 5, 2025 HHS, National Institutes of Health (NIH) Violation. Grant spending from February to June ran about $8 billion below 2024.
September 15, 2025 Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), 2025 funds Violation for the Emergency Food and Shelter Program and the Shelter and Services Program. No violation for 13 other programs.
September 29, 2025 FEMA, prior-year funds Violation for three programs.
October 7, 2026 Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Community Change Grants Violation. EPA ended the program "for policy reasons."
October 7, 2026 HHS, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Violation. Grant awards nearly stopped after 2025 layoffs.

GAO found no violation in several other reviews, including the Energy Department's wind-energy actions and the Interior Department's pause of a water-recycling program, according to GAO's decision list. GAO's decisions are not binding. In the EPA case, the agency argued that Congress's July 2025 rescission of the program's unspent money made the funds unavailable. The EPA grant cancellations and the court fight over them are covered in the EPA environmental justice entry.

Some withholdings ended quickly. On June 30, 2025, the administration told states that about $6.8 billion in school funds due July 1 would not be released. The money paid for English-learner, migrant-student, teacher-training, after-school and adult-education programs. An OMB spokesperson said some of it supported a "left-wing agenda," a claim states and districts disputed. On July 25, OMB said its review was complete and released the rest, American School & University reported.

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Funding

Trump named Vought acting director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) on February 7, 2025, ProPublica reported. The bureau is funded by the Federal Reserve rather than by annual appropriations. The law caps transfers based on the Fed's "combined earnings." In November 2025, the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel read that term to mean profits. Because the Fed was running losses, Vought said the amount he could request for fiscal 2026 was "$0," Goodwin Procter wrote.

Three federal judges rejected that reading, according to the Ballard Spahr Consumer Finance Monitor. They were Judge Amy Berman Jackson of Washington, D.C., on December 30, 2025; Judge Edward Davila of California in March 2026; and Judge Ann Aiken of Oregon on September 25, 2026. On January 9, 2026, Vought told Jackson he had asked the Fed for $145 million to run the bureau through March. Paoletta later replaced Vought as the bureau's caretaker. The CFPB's enforcement retreat is covered in the corporate enforcement entry.

The Fight Over Public Apportionment Records

OMB controls agency spending through "apportionments," legally binding schedules that release money in stages. A 2022 law requires OMB to post them online within two days. In late March 2025, OMB took the database offline. Vought told DeLauro it disclosed "sensitive, predictive, and deliberative information," FedScoop reported. GAO told the White House the takedown broke the law, saying apportionments "cannot be predecisional or deliberative."

Two watchdog groups, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) and Protect Democracy, sued. On July 21, 2025, U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan ordered the site restored. He called OMB's position "an extravagant and unsupported theory of presidential power." On August 9, a D.C. Circuit panel unanimously refused to pause his order, and OMB restored the site in mid-August, Roll Call reported. The Justice Department kept appealing.

The fight then moved to footnotes. CREW found that at least 131 of 2,245 apportionment documents approved from March 24 to September 5, 2025, referred to spending plans that were not public. Sullivan ruled that those plans must be published because they set binding limits on spending, Washington Technology reported on February 2, 2026.

The 2025 Shutdown

The government shut down from October 1 to November 12, 2025, for 43 days, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget noted. During the shutdown, OMB paused or canceled about $26 billion in infrastructure and clean-energy projects in states that lean Democratic, ProPublica reported.

  • Energy projects. On October 1, Vought announced on X the cancellation of nearly $8 billion in what he called "Green New Scam funding." The Energy Department ended $7.56 billion for 223 projects. Vought said the projects were in 16 states, all of which voted for Kamala Harris in 2024, NPR reported. Energy Secretary Chris Wright said the awards had been rushed through at the end of the Biden administration.
  • New York transit. The same day, the administration froze $18 billion for New York City projects, including the Gateway rail tunnel. A federal judge ordered the Gateway money released in February 2026, as covered in the Gateway naming entry.
  • Army Corps projects. On October 17, Vought announced a pause of $11 billion in Army Corps of Engineers projects, mostly in Democratic-led states, as covered in the Army Corps entry.
  • Layoffs. On October 10, agencies laid off about 4,000 workers across seven agencies, Government Executive reported. Vought said he expected more than 10,000 layoffs. On October 15, U.S. District Judge Susan Illston of San Francisco blocked them, saying the administration was acting as if "the laws don't apply to them anymore." Justice Department lawyers argued the case belonged before federal personnel boards.

The law that ended the shutdown reversed the shutdown layoffs and funded most of the government through January 30, 2026.

2026: Slow Releases, a Fund Transfer and a Grants Rule

Congress finished most fiscal 2026 spending bills on January 23 and February 3, 2026, according to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. OMB then moved slowly to release some of the money.

  • Science. By early March, NIH had issued about 30% of the research grants it normally would have, and the National Science Foundation about 20%, the Consortium of Social Science Associations reported. OMB had changed its rules in 2025 to limit agencies' interim monthly spending to "essential expenses" such as salaries.
  • Education. OMB delayed more than $2 billion in education funds, Education Week reported. Thirty-one programs were apportioned more than four months late. The administration moved $337 million from six programs for minority-serving colleges to another program, arguing the original programs are unconstitutional. At a June 30 House hearing, Vought said OMB was working through apportionments "expeditiously." Protect Democracy and education groups sued the same day. Under court pressure, the Institute of Education Sciences spent more than $170 million in expiring fiscal 2025 funds by September 30, Education Week reported. OMB was still withholding $465 million of the institute's $789 million for fiscal 2026.
  • Secret Service money. In June 2026, OMB moved about $350 million in Secret Service funds toward White House security work tied to the new East Wing and ballroom. Sens. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) and Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) asked GAO to investigate. That is covered in the ballroom entry.
  • Grants rule. On May 29, 2026, OMB proposed a rule requiring political appointees to review federal grants and letting agencies end grants when priorities change. Congress barred OMB from finalizing it through December 11, 2026. That is covered in the grants rule entry.

The Second Pocket Rescission

On September 25, 2026, Trump sent Congress a request to cancel about $810 million from 11 accounts, all expiring September 30, Ballotpedia reported. The White House called it "nearly $1 billion." The largest item was about $567 million for an HHS refugee assistance program. The rest included money for migrant students, housing counseling, a Justice Department office that works to reduce racial tensions, and the Minority Business Development Agency, Time reported. The request said the cuts were consistent with ending taxpayer support for non-citizens and "putting Americans first." OMB ordered the funds withheld the same day.

On September 29, GAO wrote that the requests "do not permit the President to withhold the appropriations beyond the end of fiscal year 2026." Vought said GAO's view was "not a surprise." He said GAO had "changed its long-time opinion" and added, "They make their legal assessments based on whether Democrats are in the White House."

Lawmakers split. Collins said OMB "does not get to decide which programs are worth funding." Murray, the top Democrat on the Senate Appropriations Committee, called it "theft from the American people." Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) said Congress should "cut it itself" and that he was glad Vought was doing it. Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) tried to pass a bill barring funding freezes in the last 90 days before money expires. Republicans blocked it, as they had blocked earlier versions.

On September 30, California and six other states sued in federal court in Northern California. They argue that the withholding violates the Constitution's separation of powers and the Administrative Procedure Act. California Attorney General Rob Bonta said, "Just because the President doesn't like a program doesn't mean he can defund it."

The Administration's Position

The administration says it is acting within the law. At an April 16, 2026 Senate Budget Committee hearing, Vought said repeatedly, "We have not impounded anything," according to news coverage of the hearing. He said part of OMB's job is to make sure "money is well spent" and that spending must be "consistent with our agenda."

Its legal arguments run on several tracks. Vought and Paoletta argue the 1974 law is unconstitutional and that appropriations set maximums, not required amounts. OMB argues the law's text allows a president to withhold funds for 45 days even if they expire in the meantime. It also argues that slowdowns tied to policy reviews are lawful "programmatic delays," and that apportionment records are internal deliberations. The Supreme Court's September 2025 order agreed, at an early stage, that private groups likely cannot use the Administrative Procedure Act to enforce the 1974 law.

Congressional Response

Senators of both parties questioned Vought at the April 2026 hearing. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) raised unspent Community Services Block Grant funds and told Vought, "You don't have the authority to impound it." Merkley, the committee's top Democrat, said afterward, "He just lied to America."

Congress has acted on parts of the pattern. It passed the 2025 rescissions law, reversed the shutdown layoffs and paused OMB's grants rule. It has not amended the Impoundment Control Act. In August 2026, Rep. Sydney Kamlager-Dove (D-Calif.) introduced a resolution to impeach Vought. Its first article charges "abuse of power through improper impoundment of congressionally appropriated funds," starting with the January 2025 OMB memo. House Appropriations Democrats count at least $410 billion held up, based on figures DeLauro and Murray released on September 8, 2025.

Status

As of October 24, 2026:

  • GAO has issued nine decisions finding violations of the Impoundment Control Act during Trump's second term, two of them in part. It has also found that neither pocket rescission was allowed.
  • The Supreme Court has not ruled on whether pocket rescissions are legal. Its September 2025 order was explicitly not a final decision.
  • The foreign-aid case before Judge Ali and the seven-state suit over the September 2026 pocket rescission were pending.
  • Fiscal 2027 began under a stopgap spending law that runs through December 11, 2026, as covered in the grants rule entry.
  • ProPublica's "Paper Trail" podcast revisited Vought's role on October 1, 2026, describing the legality of many of these actions as unclear.